Yeah, as a form of friendly feedback, there's something vaguely untrustworthy-looking about the website, like a malware site. Actually as I think about it, there is an uncanny valley phenomenon to me, but in a malware site sense.
To me it has something to do with the typeface choices, and/or the text layout. My eye drifts to the text in the upper left quadrant.
Lack of actual photos is maybe another thing but for me personally there's more to it than that.