If your entire life (identity and finance) is gated by a single password, a user will Care more and that makes it easier to use and remember.
In other words, having your wallet behind the same password supports adoption.
I think the 'web3' way would make it worse wouldn't it? like metamask relying on centeralized service to query the blockchain
I guess a real benifit I could see would be being able to use a blockchain to revoke your keys somehow but that's not how metamask and web3 stuff seems to work right now
The chrome extension to cryptography would help - but we have FIDO that does exactly that (and webauthn i guess).
The problem with using PK cryptography is that if you lose your keys, you'd be locked out.
Then we would probably have other key schemes M-of-N etc or social proof to compensate for the problems with single-key PK, which then has other problems.
The asym crypto is enough for proper authentication, but decentralized apps generally are built to use it, without relying on centralized data. A message signature being verified by a stateless service is all that is required
Could do without web3, but the practice of predatory web giants and smaller startups is to exploit the users so they don't do that