OVHcloud fire class action reaches 140 clients, seeks more than €10m
datacenterdynamics.com
datacenterdynamics.com
That's how they remain so low cost, they skimp on everything they can, like Ryanair.
If i can draw an analogy, it'd be like buying food from a food truck selling very cheap seafood, which follows all relevant regulations, but has a booklet describing how that seafood takes a week to get to them, and you get sick. Yes, they should do their job better, but nobody can act surprised.
I suspect that opens up negligence, which may route you around legal barriers like SLAs and TOS, depending on the laws where this lawsuit is happening. And of course, you don't have to win in court to win. You can just be enough of a cost, nuisance, or PR problem to get a settlement.
[1] https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/ovhcloud-fire-rep...
It’s kind of incredible that they wouldn’t spend $50 or $100 to backup their data, but suddenly it’s worth an average of $70,000.
Negligence could describe the clients too.
On the other hand, would OVH had power-kill switches and extinguishers, some clients may have ended up not losing their data, even as the fire occurred.
This DC was designed for no power loss and with nah-there-wont-be-any-fire hopetimism. Lawsuit is imo fully deserved.
I suspect that'd only be the case if these are in contravention of building/fire codes. Is that the case? Given that the building is a datacenter, it might be subject to less regulations compared to something like an apartment.
Ryanair has arguably the best safety record of any airline in the world (with no fatal accidents or incidents in their history, and an order of magnitude more flights/PAX PA than the other contenders such as Hawaiian), so they definitely don't skimp on everything.
For OVH, though, the "safety" of their servers (i.e. availability/durability) is one of those things they can skimp on — because unlike for people, for servers, "safety" is just another fungible thing to optimize as part of OpEx.
One of the fundamental tenets of IT operations is that hardware can just fail, datacenters can just catch fire(!), backhoes can just cut cables, etc. — and so businesses that care, architect their stacks to be resilient to these failure modes, using multi-AZ replication and so forth. And if everybody who actually cares is already doing that... then it really doesn't matter if your DC goes up in smoke.
(And also, to these same companies, low cost can have a "safety" all its own. Rather than lowering OpEx, you can instead see the calculus as: for the price of one vertically-scaled AWS instance, you can get four equivalent OVH boxes in different regions, and replicate between them. Which one of those options is "safer"?)
Mind you, if anything got burnt up that had real SLAs on it — for example, if they were offering an DBaaS service out of that datacenter — they'd be in trouble. But some leased bare-metal boxes? Nah.
I seriously doubt that they have systematically better safety than many other European companies.
Ryanair is also a relatively young company compared to other air companies, and flights are mostly within Europe, not inter continents.
I took a Ryanair plane once, that plane was a complete wreck and I thought I'd die. No more. And all things considered they aren't even that cheap since they often fly from remote airports in the middle of nowhere, so you need to get there first, wasting money and time.
Let's see what will come out of this.
And these knuckleheads got to build one in what sounds like a wooden hut with no electrical cut off? Sheesh!
In order to receive a CO in the US, an inspection has to be done to show that the build was done according to the plans on file. Part of that is a fire safety plan. You have to show max occupancy for any room in the space. That max number is determined by the size of the room, the number of egress points, the size of the doors, etc. Then the fire marshal sends a rep to insepct everything.
So just from all of that exeprience, it has nothing to do with people living there and surprised me that it is not done in a similar fashion in the EU
It's extremely hard to extinguish a full-blown electrical fire, backed by UPS batteries and other nasty chemicals and supported by a multi-megawatt power connection.
You don't need to harm people directly. The fumes' effects are enough of an hazard for people already.
The best non wetting extinguisher gas, Novec needs a week to decompose completely, and it was the shortest time when we were building our data center.
Another poster pointed out that the data center had wooden ceilings! That’s insane!
That's also why you go with a real cloud as soon as you raise enough funding.
Harder if you're heavily relying on the more advanced services with often provider-specific APIs, but I think if you host with OVH you're likely to be primarily renting machines.
Seriously.. weren’t these people just waiting for something bad to happen? And now that something bad did happen, they want someone else to pay for it.. because they wouldn’t pay for the cheapest of measures to protect their property they claim was so valuable. Have you looked at how cheap hard drives are today?
I know for a fact that I do. Yes, I was affected by the fire, and had to pull the backups and rebuild the whole stack - we got a few hours of downtime. And yet I stayed with OVH, the main reason being that, even taking into account this unfortunate event, you get a great value for your money. Of course, some businesses can't afford any downtime: in this case, whichever provider one chooses, they have to go multi-cloud, or at least distribute their setup on multiple regions. I have been burned (figuratively!) in the past all the same with big names cloud provider... Shit just happens, be prepared!
Because OVH's negligence transpires more widely than just in DC fires. I've had my primary business domain name almost expire twice due to OVH's incompetence. I should have run away the first time. I finally did the second time. Never again, thankyouverymuch.
Some low cost providers do offer acceptable quality. OVH was (is?) not one of those.
As long as you don't need any of the services that only the big 3 offer, I don't see a reason why I would prefer AWS over OVH or Hetzner.
derp: https://lowendspirit.com/discussion/2317/a-year-in-les-refle...
Which begs the question, what do their DCs look like?
He also has a newer video showing the power distribution, cooling, and fire suppression in one of the Dr Oetker datacentres: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bpTNcbnZjvY
Hetzner is also known to do everything in-house, slows them down building new dcs and expanding to new locations but keeps cost down and the company independent.