What if the government said it was optional, but those who sign up get a 2% discount on their taxes? Would you find that more acceptable?
I guess I was more curious if the main point of contention was the mandatory part of it or whether it was more about the fact it was coming from the government. I think some people distrust government so much that even if it were offered as opt-in, using a similar approach as a private company, some people would still trust a private company more than their government.