CA Court: Bumblebees can be legally considered fish
reuters.com
reuters.com
Saved you the click.
Here, the list purports to enumerate “fish.” And the other items on the list are marine animals, like mollusks. So the best statutory construction would be that, in this context, “invertebrates” means “marine invertebrates.” Which is almost certainly what the legislature meant.
But this is California after all!
As a lawyer, you should know better than to make an underinformed unqualified statement about matters of law.
If the legislature intended “fish” to mean something other than “fish and fish-like things” they could have changed the definition. They chose not to do that. The fact that the “expert” agencies have been flouting the law for decades doesn’t change the meaning of the words on the page.
Also, as the superior court observed, the legislature expressly rejected efforts to add “invertebrates” to the list of protected animals.
> As a lawyer, you should know better than to make an underinformed unqualified statement about matters of law.
I’m commenting on what the interpretation should be in this straightforward case, not offering an opinion on what a California court may or may not do. Here, the superior court offered a well reasoned decision finding that insects are not fish: https://fingfx.thomsonreuters.com/gfx/legaldocs/klvykolmmvg/...
The appellate court had to spend a lot of pages and did a lot of hand waving to overcome the clear words on the page. But that contrivance diminishes the persuasiveness of the opinion, it doesn’t enhance it!
Mollusks, like the broader group of invertebrates, include both aquatic and terrestrial species.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrestrial_mollusc
Crustaceans also include some terrestrial species (most woodlice, for instance.)
So your argument premised on the other groups in the list being aquatic is fatally flawed: fish are aquatic, sure, but crustaceans and mollusks can be aquatic or terrestrial, and amphibians are...amphibious.
So, your argument that they didn't meant “aquatic invertebrate” when they said “invertebrate” is based on the fact that “crustacean” and “mollusk” are unambiguously aquatic, and that the fact that these unambiguously aquatic terms were used means that “invertebrate” was implicitly restricted.
But your claim that “crustacean” and “mollusk” are unambiguously aquatic relies on exactly the same unstated restriction, as both are terms that encompass terrestrial species, and your support for that is...what?
Compared to the extensive analysis of the legislative history and context in the opinion supporting the opposite conclusion, this is singularly unpersuasive.