"...making the citizens of our city miserable in service of an ideology that made sense everywhere but in reality"
"...making the citizens of our city miserable in service of an ideology that made sense everywhere but in reality"
> "...making the citizens of our city miserable in service of an ideology that made sense everywhere but in reality"
It should be the motto of more than just those cities. I think people often get blinkered by ideologies that are "satisfyingly simple" and fall into a kind of "ideology-X realism" trap, where they confuse the ideological formulations for reality, and so stop paying attention to actual reality.
You see the same thing lot with "econ 101" style thinking that omits the rough edges and complexity of reality to make a "free market" ideological program feel silky-smooth and perfect.
I think a lot of people ignore the realities of progressive policies, because to them, progressive policy means fighting systemic racism/sexism/etc. It doesn't have to work - all that matters is the intention. And you can't even argue, because then you're just a racist/sexist/etc, because who else would argue against them?
The original comment and your response seems to react to what some academics call “complex systems”—people and preferences (in this case).
If I’m reading this response correctly, there is a charge that simple models are being applied to complex systems. And some peoples don’t like the outcomes. (I have to be careful here myself, making such a simple statement lest I go from the pan into the fire-—I recognize some people who “don’t like outcomes” are fighting for social recognition and civil rights).
Back to my point…the definition of ‘ideology’ which I find useful comes from Peter Sloterdijk's 1983 book, “Critique of Cynical Reason” where he explored the rationale of cynicism and social discontent.
Sloterdijk describes the difficulty of an argument with someone intent on lying to you. Take that a step further. Its an order of magnitude more difficult to find agreement with someone who has a false belief (ie. a witness to an event who has a false belief because of a unconscious bias). Finally, he defines “ideology” as an personal and internal idea—unexpressed—of how the world works.
In the above example of a queer woman of color objecting to the appointment of a queer white person, that’s not an internal and unexpressed personal belief driving their argument. Her argument is right there in the open.
The first one is impossible problem and the second one is a complex problem.
[1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complex_system
[2]: https://www.google.com/books/edition/Critique_of_Cynical_Rea...
Brother, wait until you find out that Trumpism and Wokism are not the only ways to run a government.
But they certainly have drug and poverty problems too.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_and_territ...
You also agree with other people down the thread to "look outside the US". Well, there are cities and countries with real progressive ideals that are operating quite well for their citizens.
I believe reforms to better care for the homeless and the addicted, to provide better social safety nets, requires a host of changes and may need to be done at a scale higher than a city.
That all said, it does seem SF has fucked up in ways that need backed out or tried a different way.
"But people addicted to drugs come from all over the country in part for the services San Francisco provides."
So, because other cities are tough on drugs (including the famous "three strikes" laws where you can receive a life sentence if you get caught with drugs three times), and San Francisco treats drug addicts more humanely, drug addicts from all over the US tend to migrate to San Francisco. Making the citizens of the city miserable. Hmmm...
(But within the state, San Francisco County is indeed perhaps the laxest with regards to sentencing.)
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2017/dec/...
The article was written back in ~2016~(the end of 2017),it really needs to be revisited, but the sentiment of "go to where there are services for your problem" does indeed exist.