B == "Inconsistency between your caches"
GP: A -> B
You: "Imposing order and synchrony is [bad things]" == "If you don't do A then [bad things]", i.e., (not A) -> [bad things]
Also you: "Even if we did, then [other issues]" == "Even if you don't do A then [other issues]", i.e., (not A) -> ..what? B?
You are certainly not arguing against the A -> B implication.