The more measured position against student loan forgiveness is:
-People in the trades who did not go to college should not be paying for people who did. College degree holders already have high earning power.
-There is a moral hazard that comes from not holding people accountable to their own decisions. People will assume (perhaps logically) that there will always be a bail out. This same thing happened in the stock market for rich people via the "fed put."
-We have inflation at generational highs with extremely low employment - this will exacerbate the issue.
-Forgiveness that is decoupled from fixing the underlying system doesn't actually solve the problem. Will we do forgiveness every X years without making college more affordable? (you correctly made this point)
-Forgiveness is a misnomer - in reality it is a tax we all have to pay and is much more akin to a transfer payment.
-What values are we trying to teach our children about decision making and accountability? Victim mentality is becoming more common.