Always start with a conversation...
"you have never seen that movie ? let's play it"
"wait I don't see it on netflix, neither on prime or disney or...I should have bought the vhs/DVD/blueray at the time."
Not sure if you can find most +2y old movies on torrent platforms, last time I checked I couldn't find what I was looking for. I lament the death of local videoclubs where you could rent movies from any decade.