Some of the worst candidates have had the best resumes. I'd bet good money they could have talked coherently about their projects, made it sound like they'd cured cancer. But when I asked them to do something not much harder than FizzBuzz on a whiteboard, they choked. Ask them to intersect two lists? They'd use Excel. Ask them how Excel would implement that? They freeze, the interview is over. This was a normal pattern. Thankfully, our recruiters started asking pulse-checking questions, and the number of these interviews dropped.
Interviews need something that can't be directly prepared for and directly rehearsed. Unfortunately, I don't think your solution has provided that. I think it would tend to hire silvertongued people who cut and paste.