Thanks for the question.
The point I am making is that if the capabilities of multi-modal neural models continues to improve, it will become harder to convince folks one way or the other.
The reason I went with that scenario is that I thought it would be compelling and evocative, as well as a logical extreme of AI agency in human lives.
I personally find the entire question meaningless for the most part, although it's really interesting the divide in peoples opinions on the topic.