There is actually no upside limit, but there is a fundamental downside limit of zero.
What justifies oil being $130 dollars a barrel vs $100? The answer is also nothing.
What justifies oil being $130 dollars a barrel vs $100? The answer is also nothing.
The fact that it is used in daily productive activity might be an argument that oil should in theory have a > 0 price, however the actual price is still made up by a market! There is still not a way to say that the intrinsic value of oil must be X dollars.
I actually never considered that!
If I can make $10/hour running a generator, then I'm willing to pay up to $10 in fuel to operate it
Note: I completely agree with you on the concept of an equilibrium price being a real thing, I just don't think equilibrium is determined by intrinsic value.