Apple iMessage ‘edit’ and ‘undo send’ buttons risk enabling sex abuse: attorney | Hacker News Reader

Apple iMessage ‘edit’ and ‘undo send’ buttons risk enabling sex abuse: attorney

nypost.com

13 pointsmikece6 comments

Once again, Apple gives control over phones to people other than their owners, and bad things resulted. Once a message ends up on your phone, nobody but you should be able to do anything to it.

Screenshots still work and should be about as strong when used as proof in court as messages in the (modifiable) on-device database, no? Besides, other messengers have offered message deletion for a long time now.

The real risk to users seems to be the opposite: Message deletion, "view once" functionality etc. can create the (false) impression that text and media sent on these platforms are more ephemeral than they really are: The recipient can always take a screenshot.

Depends. I once was an expert witness against someone who “lost” the original email they doctored and printed out. DKIM signatures and spam prevention proved my client had an original, undoctored email saying something totally different from the other person.

That was fun. But generally, both parties have to accept the screenshot you have is authentic, otherwise you just have some text on a piece of paper which might convince a jury.

Interesting! But that's precisely my point: iMessage does not have anything comparable to DKIM, as far as I understand (it's using ECDSA internally for authentication, but as far as I know, signatures are not stored to the persistent message database locally). A copy of the local message database "without headers" is no better or worse than a screenshot of a message contained in it.

Apple might be able to provide the original ECDSA signature from their server-side logs, but even there, nothing changes with editable/deletable messages: If that capability exists, it will continue existing (unless Apple somehow starts dropping traffic logs specifically for edited/deleted messages).

I can't for the life of me understand why anybody sexts.

It’s fun

Reply on news.ycombinator.com