The more interesting but unasked Q to me is, How much food would be saved if they just did away with the dining halls? People that pay for each component of each meal probably waste considerably less food than the pre-paid assembly line of junk.
The more interesting but unasked Q to me is, How much food would be saved if they just did away with the dining halls? People that pay for each component of each meal probably waste considerably less food than the pre-paid assembly line of junk.
* It is more efficient -- no need to bill for every item, so just tap your RFID card on the way in.
* It is usually billed in the general proximity of tuition, so if parents are paying they can be sure the money is spent on food rather than beer.
* Students are in a weird spot, lots of stuff is being thrown at them (studying of course, and might be away from home for the first time). It is nice to take the financial concern out of the nutritional balance calculus.
* If the admin is motivated, they can simplify the waste stream (it is centrally managed and lends itself to buffet style, so they can make sure everything that the students get is biodegradable -- the waste should just be compost).
Plus is is a nice community space.
> It is more efficient -- no need to bill for every item, so just tap your RFID card on the way in.
The items were just quickly added up by a person at the end of the line, then you'd scan your student barcode/tap an RFID card and be billed for that amount. This was never the bottleneck in getting served.
> It is usually billed in the general proximity of tuition, so if parents are paying they can be sure the money is spent on food rather than beer.
You were billed in arrears at the start of the next term, so it was clear the money was going to the college (you could also use your card in the college bar, but IIRC this was itemised differently so parents could check if they want).
> It is nice to take the financial concern out of the nutritional balance calculus.
Certainly nice, but removing trays may skew the balance in other ways (FTA "trayless dining decreased the percentage of diners who took salad by 65.2 percent but did not decrease the percentage who took dessert").
> they can make sure everything that the students get is biodegradable / Plus is is a nice community space.
Most people ate in halls anyway (the accommodation only had very rudimentary cooking facilities), so the first is still doable and we gathered as a group to dine most evenings. You'd also meet other people who happened to go at the same time.
And probably not just with time efficiency. The dining hall has economies of scale compared to putting a kitchenette in every dorm room/suite.
It's almost definitely more space efficient. It's probably also more energy efficient.
My freshman year I ate in the dining hall. I primarily ate Lucky Charms for every meal. I’m not sure how much nutritional balance calculus I was doing.
That’s the calculus you avoided.
Predictability has value. Economists may argue that more variables let you optimize systems. But real humans have a limited ability to pay attention to their economics.
Getting rid of trays looks like an obvious winner. But paying for every item in a dining hall would be a sucky UX and lead to perverse outcomes because customers will find the product hard to use.
Personally, sometimes (not always) I have been in a buffet and the quality is very low because some people eat as much as they can. In that context I would gladly have paid per item. Point one, quality may change when charged per item.
> But paying for every item in a dining hall would be a sucky UX and lead to perverse outcomes because customers will find the product hard to use.
I basically only disagree with you on this one. This is exactly how restaurants work, and customers do not find it hard to use. They still often have a menu to combine a subset of all the items available under a common pricing.
IMO it is cultural. I believe it is a combination of two factors:
First, do we think of the students as intelligent creatures, with discerning capabilities, or as cattle to be fed?
And second, do we value the quality of food, or it is just a problem to be solved at the minimum cost?
Paying per component or buffet can both work. I do not think one is more efficient/rational. Quality, freshness of product, amount of food wasted, variance in price, health implications, can change a lot between both approaches.