I'd wish folks focused on the incredible amount of engineering that has gone into wasmer. The breadth of its offering is astonishing for a team of its size. Sad that the engineering team couldn't be together for longer, but the runtime is impressive nevertheless.
I look at wasmer's various OSS repos from time to time to understand how it was put together. It has been very rewarding to say the least.
(yes, I am also aware of the fallout between Syrus, the founder, and a few ex wasmer engs, but let's also focus on the good parts too, folks!)
That said, trademarking WebAssembly seems to spit in the face of the engineering and technical design work that went into WebAssembly before even Wasmer arrived. Perhaps not as sleek and polished as a VC-backed startup, but we can praise Wasmer for what it has accomplished while also expressing reservations regarding the people who stand to profit from its success.
No, as many readers possible should be informed. This no name startup attempted to steal what was supposed to be a standard runtime format. Imagine what they’d do on a larger scale with that sort of behavior. That’s not a company that deserves to grow, we have enough Google’s and Apple’s.
A lot of these companies play good guy by open sourcing their products. Given this one’s commercial struggle, who says they genuinely want the world to see their code, Is it not possible they have no other choice?
An open source, closed spec product doesn’t really add up, it’s ingenuine, greedy, and downright stagnant.
In which case violates the site's guidelines:
> Eschew flamebait. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents.
Seems like unethical behaviour on their part is related to their product offering.
And it is pertinent that there are alternatives like wasmtime that don’t have such issues.
I'm glad for the sliver of technical discussion that did occur in this thread, but most of it was "controversy" that has been discussed over and over before and is pointless.
Personally I think this forum is best when the discussion steers more technical, especially in a tech related thread.
The constant scarlet lettering is tiring.
HN is an advertising medium for tech companies. That’s why it exists. When I and others in this thread see an unethical company benefiting from that exposure, we feel compelled to point out that the company is unethical. That way the target audience for the tech product can make an informed choice about whether they want to do business with unethical folks.
If you feel our comments are off topic, go ahead and flag/downvote.
But I’m guessing it’ll be like tilting at windmills.
> Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity.
What you're doing is violating the guideline:
> Please don't pick the most provocative thing in an article or post to complain about in the thread. Find something interesting to respond to instead.
I did flag your comments as I feel it violates that guideline at least, and I feel your tone violates others.
On a personal note you at least motivated me to use Wasmer in the future, though I may have chosen them anyway for the performance.
Your crusade may not be having the effect that you think it is.
And my crusade? Look at my comments on this thread, I’ve only replied to you. (And I’ve never commented on wasmer before, to my knowledge). I’ve tried to explain to you why everyone else talks about the shady things this company does. And for explaining that to you, I get condescended to.
The guidelines are what HN aspires to be. It’s a good goal. What I told you was what HN actually is. It’s why Ycombinator funds this website. It’s why tech companies strategise on how best to get attention from HN. How to write blog posts that HN will like. When to post to get the most upvotes and views.
You can blind yourself to that reality if you want. You can go ahead and use whatever tech you want. It’s really no skin off my back. Have a nice day :)
* Intel (WAMR) - Market cap: $105B
* Fastly (Wasmtime) - Market cap: $1.2B
* Google (V8) - Market cap: $1.5T
* Tetrate Labs (Wazero) - Market cap: ~$200M (guesstimate)[1] -https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_trademarked_open-sourc...
Web assembly isn't just Wasmer. This move is like trying to trademark "internet" or "hyperlink" or "metaverse".
It seems part of the motivation for Wasmer to apply for the trademark was because they felt snubbed by the Bytecode alliance [^2] and wanted to start their own foundation (with blackjack and hookers, presumably). The Bytecode alliance doesn't own any of the trademarks either, and seems to be more of a collaborative effort, but is worth mentioning as part of the overall story.
[^1]: Groups listed here: https://webassembly.org/. and members here: https://www.w3.org/Consortium/Member/List and https://www.w3.org/community/webassembly/participants. Note that a few Wasmer employees (the CEO, for one) belong to the community group, but don't chair it.
[^2]: https://bytecodealliance.org/ and https://wasmer.io/posts/wasmer-and-trademarks
Software is a hard and complex thing to build, people don't tend to work full-time on projects which they can't earn a living from.
> Software is a hard and complex thing to build, people don't tend to work full-time on projects which they can't earn a living from.
Wouldn't these be positive points towards how Wasmer is running the company? They are trying to keep their open source product alive by marketing and finding a way to build revenue, to continue to fund development.
In the end, if they fail, it's all open source, someone can fork and continue it if the demand is there. Until then, they are the ones doing it, and doing it well imo.
It seems like people are specifically interested in spreading FUD about Wasmer and I can't see the justification for it.
It is as if Nodejs tried to trademark V8
Sure it's open source, but unless you're at a scale where you actually can take it over and maintain it, that's not some magical escape hatch.
This isn't a theoretical thing for me. I've got a project in mind that wasmer would be a candidate for, and I ruled it out for this reason.