My defense of Lex is incidental of trying to achieve my primary goal of highlighting how juvenile the negative comments are.
This isn't the first time this question has been asked, and it seems like the question was asked earnestly. However, it's clear there is a lot of jealousy at the root of the negative opinions. I'm guessing this is because Lex has access to so many interesting people for such long periods of time. People responding that he's a wet blanket or that they don't like him aren't even trying to answer the question. What kind of format are they expecting to hear when interviewing academics? Jimmy Fallon meets Bill O'Reilly interviewing a Democrat?
Ask HN: "Why is Lady Gaga successful?" Average response here: "Ugh, I can't stand her."