Your argument reminds me—painfully—of arguments in favour of physical bullying. “Hey, a few clouts to the head and he’ll get the idea.”
I don’t hit my children, no matter how stubborn they are.
I don’t hit my children, no matter how stubborn they are.
Edit: I'm not saying that the original argument is correct, as it really isn't, but your response was a straw man.
I fail to see how this contributes to anything.