Apple store workers vote to form first US union
bbc.co.uk
bbc.co.uk
What am I missing?
Unions protect workers against wrongful firing, intimidation by management, and number of other situations the average person would find unacceptable, but otherwise had no recourse.
Note, some employers actually have good relationships with their unions; it pretty much comes down to how much a company cares about its workers, as people who are primarily trying to make a living.
Ignoring the union question, they are paid to smile at you, doesn't mean they all are happy to work there in anyway. They are strongly encouraged to be "friendly, responsive" and appear "to truly want to help you" by management, it's an act.
I have hard time believing anybody would think most Apple store employees genuinely feel that way when they have to deal with douche bag clients and suffer terrible management all day long. Source is myself.
Not long ago a full-time job was enough to support a family.
This goes especially for frontline or storage workers or anyone else who is frequently seen by management as "easily replaceable".
The most common answer to this is that unions protect the worst employees, and tends to equalize wages so that the better employees are paid the same as the worst. If you're more talented, why should you expect equal pay to everyone else?
Unions reward mediocrity. They can (and have) certainly done good as well. But this is the most common critique of unions.
Unions have an incentive for the company to be healthy and profitable - just not at the expense of the workers.
Also, "talented" seems very vague to me. Of course everyone would like to be exceptionally talented and be placed above the others, but who in the end decides of you are talented or not and on which criteria?
This seems a bit like the "temporarily embarrassed millionaires" situation, where you can be tempted to give up security in the present for some idealized but highly uncertain future.
The fact is, there are a ton of shitty employees. Anybody who has ever worked with others, knows that. In a union environment, those people are paid the same. That naturally grates on a lot of people. If you work with someone who does the same job as you, but poorly...you would rightfully expect to be paid more.
I don't want this to come off as me saying unions are shit, but the question was asked why would people ever not support unions and that's generally why.
Well yes, it does. After all, the employer doesn't trust me either, otherwise we wouldn't have a whole industry of performance monitoring tools, time tracking systems, access control solutions, etc.
You cannot expect one side to pretend we're all a big family while the other does not.
> I highly doubt most management teams see workers as "easily replaceable" especially considering how hard it is to get workers these days.
Then go ahead and chat with a few Amazon warehouse workers or Starbucks Baristas or Uber drivers.
Or Amazon developers for that matter: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31789381
As for mistrust, not necessarily. The basic idea of a better balance of power can simply insure good people stay good. In the case of newly formed unions, the overwhelming majority already have mistrust and cause for it.
Hate towards management is simple and works like auto mechanics do; namely, there are enough shoddy ones to give the good ones a challenge to maintain a good reputation. At lower wage scales, there is a lot of bad management.
Your last statement varies considerably by industry. Let's just say making people replaceable or even making them feel replaceable or have the perception of being replaceable is very high on the priority list for a lot of management.