Hundreds of thousands of people work there, yet they haven't managed to achieve that positive impact.
Hundreds of thousands of people work there, yet they haven't managed to achieve that positive impact.
Search, Maps, Gmail, YouTube, Chrome, Android, Cloud, Pixel, Nest, Fitbit, Stadia, Drive? Not to mention their other projects like DeepMind / AlphaFold?
Pixel is just another phone. Fitbit, Deepmind, YouTube and Nest are not Google's. They were bought. And YouTube is a net negative impact.
Android was also acquired, and that was purely to get more control over the user and their data, as was Google Docs and Gmail. Google's management of Android is frankly horrid. Their security update policy? Buy a new phone, loser, and agree to our new terms of use!
Chrome isn't even an original Google project, but forked from WebKit, again with the intention to control the user and their data, and preferably wall them in.
No, Google has had a negative impact on the world over the last years, and they will have it as long as they dominate the markets. And the people that work on it can see it.
You don't reach billions of users without positively impacting people who use your service. If there was no positive impact people would simply abandon Google's and Facebook's services.
If you had an addictive drug and all it did was make all your teeth fall out with no extra side effects almost no one would take it.
While yes, Meth is dangerous and addictive I don't think what Google and Facebook are doing is bad. How is Google giving people access to the world's data or Facebook connecting the world a bad thing? They are trying to do good things and are constantly trying to reduce the harm their services bring to people. They have entire organizations within these companies for doing so.
I can't help but notice that you dropped "positive" here, and I can only assume it's on purpose, as otherwise your argument would like quite silly. People using something does not mean it's positive. The list doesn't really stop at meth.
>by selling other peoples data
Neither of these companies sell user data. Both these companies take user privacy more seriously than almost every other company on Earth.
That depends on your idea of privacy. Collecting and retaining incredible amounts of data about people even without their consent isn’t my idea of respecting privacy.
If you only care about getting a good pay from such a job, fine. But that just makes you immoral in my book.
Every part of that sentence was wrong, and you are trying to pretend otherwise.
(And more in the spirit of the specific question parent raised - someone working at Facebook on funding charities. Are they "bad" for doing that job?)