Why The Flow Of Innovation Has Reversed
unionsquareventures.com
unionsquareventures.com
The basic premise of the article is wrong. NASA specifically, may not play as large a role as it once did, but (most) innovation is still very much a top-down process. Even twitter (which I've seen hailed as innovative again and again) is just a hack on SMS, which of course was not developed by consumers.
He also seems to be implying that web 2ish "social engineering" has outpaced electrical engineering as a means of innovation, which is at best a confusion between the application layer and underlying technology stack.
I don't mean to say that consumer-led innovation can never produce radically new technologies, just that the general direction of innovation is still top-down.
They all are dependent much more on the innovation of others (the cell companies, ISPs, open source software). I haven't heard of many technologies developed at Facebook or Twitter that are being used by NASA or other traditional giants, while I have heard of the converse.
I don't understand why you don't think that's innovative. The definition of innovative is to introduce something as though it was new (http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/innovate), which is a far cry from invention. Innovation isn't about creating new things, it's about taking established things and making them appeal to people in a new way.
In that sense, a real innovation is something that is well understood, and tested for its benefit. The thing about craigslist, twitter, facebook, wikipedia, etc is that the real reason that they are so valuable is only a matter of speculation at this point. They are only the beginning of the experiment - not the final output.
You can take a circuit level innovation, and re-apply it in several contexts. You can't take the magic of craigslist or facebook and incur the same value in another situation.. all you can do is speculate on why it worked, and be another iteration of a highly distributed experiment.
What the author is calling innovation, is really just leveraging off the reduced costs of infrastructure to test new tools on consumers. When someone formalizes why the 'social engineering' approaches work, predictably, against this data set, they will then be able to improve, and re-apply with more certainty in the market. That's innovation. I'm not sure how rigorous 'social engineering' is at present, but maybe 'social experimenters' is a better name.
Take a simplified example of a printing press. One step is developing the steam powered press (NASA like). Another is inventing the newspaper (more like twitter).
The kinds of innovations we seem to think we are seeing today are clever tricks compared to the kind of R&D that went into NASA's frankly glorious history of innovation. The resources and incredible intellectual capital that had to be (and still has to be) invested in a new launch vehicle, satellite, or manned craft is just orders of magnitude higher than what is required for innovation of the internet-startup kind.
None of this should be seen to denigrate the innovations that are minting millionaires and billionaires today. Indeed, the truly wondrous thing is that a mere clever trick can make you for life. Unless I'm missing something (and I'm not, at least here), this is the very reason that ycombinator and Hacker News exist at all; You can fund significant innovation that may earn $10^6-$10^9 for $10^4.
For a contemporary example of the difference between these two kinds of innovation, just look at SpaceX. Elon Musk made his money the clever trick way (low initial capital + clever trick + hard work + wonder of the internet) and is now engaged in the "old school" way of making money with innovation (high capital + lots of Ph.Ds + hard work of 100s to 1000s of people + rigorous design, construction, and testing).
Huh? NASA didn't produce much innovation. Bell Labs did. Edison did. GE did. Heck, even GM and Ford had their day. NASA - not so much.
Even if we restrict ourselves to innovation by govt organizations, NASA is behind at least two of the national labs.
Back in the late 50's NASA and ARPA were two of the biggest customers for computer innovation. Now we are (where we is Internet users in general, not HN readers).
I used to work at NASA's TDRSS installation and innovation and new ideas are not really their thing. Maintaining their amazing uptime is, though.