Giving birth to that child: stay pregnant for a few more months, go through labor, and ACTUALLY raise that child by buying the food, paying for and sending them to school, paying for a lot of other stuff, and spending time with them for TWO DECADES which you may not be mentally or financially prepared for
Why is this even a question? You think a mother gives birth to a child and it's done business, like abortion?
And if so, who determines when the cut off is? If the fetus is still attached to the mother after it leaves the birth canal, I still consider it her body, so is i still her choice?
So we agree where the cutoff is. As in, we discuss in congress and find some point we can agree on. Perhaps using European democracies as a guide, where things range from up to 12 weeks after conception to 6 months after conception.
We could perhaps work "from first principles". Obviously abortion needs to happen after a woman knows she's pregnant. So, you should allow at least 1-2 female periods' worth (1 period = 4 weeks) + some time to schedule the procedure, which comes to that same minimum of about 12 weeks.
An exception is medically necessary abortion, which is even legal (and a fact of life) after the baby leaves the birth canal (a baby without lungs will stay alive as long as the umbilical cord is intact, for example. When you cut it, and you have to cut it, baby dies. Not much can be done. And this is not the worst example by far. Though it's natural, so you might say "Approved by God", by republican logic).
I must say this is one thing I don't understand about the religious position. Several abortion procedures are built into our genes (one relating to the immune system, one relating to the heart, one relating to the brain, and I doubt we've discovered all of them).
Either those systems work to a minimum standard, or your own cells (or the mother's cells) will abort you. So there are very practical reasons that "God" does abortions. The theory is that these systems exist, because it vastly lowers the time it takes to produce another child, increasing the rate at which your DNA spreads. This also exists in animals (most famously male lions' post-natal abortions when they take over a troup).
Canada has proven that is not true. In Canada, it is entirely between the woman and her doctor, right up until birth. If she could find a doctor to do it (spoiler alert: she won’t) she could abort minutes before contractions begin.
And this is the way it should be. Doctors and the hospitals behind them don’t perform late term abortions unless they are medically necessary.
In Canada there are no laws, no legal limits, and there is no problem. Funny how that works, eh? It’s almost as if we can trust doctors and women.
When discussing value of life people usually pick their preferred side. Do homeless people have a value on life? America treats homeless as garbage. What about disabled people?
People do this all over the world.
> Strangers are not going to help raise the child, like back in tribe ages where there so many children that everyone in the tribe had a part.
and
> The social benefits from government when you have a child are abysmal even in the "good" states in America.
So why are we not addressing these things? But actually, that is what adoption is all about. True? Stranger raisin your baby?
> When discussing value of life people usually pick their preferred side.
I don't. I do not discuss their value monetarily at all. That is incomprehensible. By the way, I am homeless, and yes, I see both Democrats and Republicans treat me like garbage. They both do not care about life at any point.
Again, look at this. No one wants to elect people to fix these problems, we just keep on voting in these corporate capitalism politicians and then they tell you to just have an abortion because you cannot afford the high cost of everything and the low wages.
I am not anti-abortion, I just want a society where they are not needed becasue money.
* There is something wrong with the child, due to which any semblance happy and fulfilled life will never be possible
* The child is a product of an unwanted and traumatic sexual contact
* The mother knows she can't support the child and will end up raising it on the street - until she can't any more
The pro-life crowd should actively work to ensure every mother has maternity leave and comprehensive support services, including healthcare, for both mother and child. Otherwise, they risk being called on their hypocrisy.
If she got pregnant out of wedlock, it's vastly worse.
You see what I mean?
If having a baby makes your life so harsh that your own survival is threatened, it's rather hard to take the high road and try to "fix society" so you can avoid an abortion.
Give me a break. This is not why the majority of women choose to have abortions and it is way over the top of na exaggeration. I know five women who had abortions. It was career for three, already had four kids for one who is wealthy, and the last did not like the guy she had the kid with but still dated him after.
> it's rather hard to take the high road and try to "fix society" so you can avoid an abortion.
But we have not addressed this the WHOLE TIME abortion was legal, and look where we are now. If we start dismantling capitalism we might be able to address why it costs so much to have a baby and why there is such an extreme divergence in wealth that makes it hard for so many people.
I have no idea why you seem so angry at me for noting that this is so for some people and those individuals usually are not in a good position to "fix society" much less both have a baby and also fix society.
We'd need to fix American society first, but then a lot of people will irrationally scream "socialism" and work against their own interests.
And then they don't really care whether you chose or not to have that baby.
Secondly, there is an uncountable number of reasons to have an abortion rather than carrying to term. I don’t know which reasons will meet your personal bar of acceptable, but we are talking about rape victims, children, mothers who cannot afford time off because there is minimal maternity leave and they need to provide for their already born kids, professionals who are building their careers, trans men with gender dysphoria, ectopic pregnancy, high-risk pregnancy, cannot afford to stop psychological medication that hasn’t been approved for pregnancy…
> Well firstly, let’s stop spreading misinformation that abortion is inherently risky.
I wasn't, other people are saying that this is what it would lead to , more women choosing these "risky" abortions.
> ectopic pregnancy, high-risk pregnancy, cannot afford to stop psychological medication that hasn’t been approved for pregnancy…
These are all self defense cases in my opinion and so I do not consider it immoral.
> rape victims
I understand this as something that would put the life of the mother at risk because of the trauma involved. So not immoral.
> children, mothers who cannot afford time off because there is minimal maternity leave and they need to provide for their already born kids,
Well this is a problem with society then, yes? Does your suffering give you the right to kill another being (Since we still have not determined when life begins you have to admit this is a possibility.)
> professionals who are building their careers
I feel this is unacceptable. People make decisions that affect their career everyday. Having sex is one of them.
When do you think life begins? I really do not know.
So how late in a pregnancy can someone determine that a fetus is going to interfere with their career?
> trans men with gender dysphoria
Just going to stay away from this one becasue I do not know enough about it.
Frankly, I don’t think any of us get to pick and choose acceptable and unacceptable reasons to have a procedure on a body that isn’t one’s own. The problem with framing abortion as if the fetus is generally viable is that, generally, it isn’t viable. It’s actually normalized not to announce pregnancy until over 3 months in because spontaneous abortions are just that common. There’s no guarantee that any given pregnancy won’t result in an abortion anyways, and gatekeeping abortion will disproportionately harm everyone involved due to the intense trauma of having the choices of one’s body taken away from them for most of a year through no activity that is illegal or worthy of punishment.
I think you have this backwards. Since we haven't defined when life begins and we know the person carrying the fetus is alive we must choose the rights and well-being of the living over the unknown. Otherwise we open ourselves up to allowing legislators to assert that this or that cell might be alive and therefore requires equal protection under the law.
They have defined when life begins which is why they have cut offs for abortion, like not after 3 months. Also this man was charged with killing an 10 week old fetus.
https://www.kansascity.com/news/local/article340575.html
You cannot murder something if we have ruled it does not have a right to life.
> Otherwise we open ourselves up to allowing legislators to assert that this or that cell might be alive and therefore requires equal protection under the law.
Not at all. The most we could go back is to say that human life begins at fertilization. The other option is when the baby leaves the birth canal. To me those are the only options that makes sense. The three month rule is idiotic.
I could say that it can feel like a life-ending situation to become pregnant but you might not really get it without some emotional connection, hence the movie references.
Alternatively, you could imagine a situation where you'd want to punch someone in the face for saying "why don't you just live with it?" and substitute that for how some women feel when they're unexpectedly pregnant.
Certainly with legal and safe abortion, many more abortions are performed than would have been in the previous regime. But just like some people will risk their career or commit suicide rather than accept a life changing event, women were willing to risk it all to avoid becoming a mother at that point in their life.
$5,000-$10,000 in medical bills to birth them. Another $200,000-$500,000 to get them to 18.
It's imaginable some might want to avoid having a child for the cost savings alone.