Wouldn’t it be nice if the complainers’ employers paid a tiny, one time $550 to open source projects they depend on.
Wouldn’t it be nice if the complainers’ employers paid a tiny, one time $550 to open source projects they depend on.
I often see that a corporation spends e.g. $1M on a marketing blitz about a $50,000 donation, or runs some campaign where consumers need to do something for some very nominal donation somewhere.
The cynic in me also looks at this as a bribe. Someone who got a $500 gift is much more likely to stay on github. Do that for the top 1000 projects, and you've stemmed the flow to gitlab.
The cynic in me became a lot more cynical when github started selling my own code back to me with copilot.
Now, this is a pseudonymous account so you obviously don’t know whether you use my projects. Just donate to whatever you use.
To expand: I see grandstanding all the time. I see precious little money flowing into my PayPal tip jar. Casual users of my completely free web services have been a lot more generous than companies/developers using my open source libraries/tools. I’m completely fine with the lack of donations, but that certainly makes all the grandstanding from stingy people who don’t give a dime very annoying.
1. From my observation, donors tend to appreciate other donors a bit more.
2. I’ve confronted a few of these people in the past. When asked how much they donated, the answer was always I don’t donate because excuses X, Y, Z. But rich companies/people must donate more; they’re all PR stunts; blah blah.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yeZ3_OtDa7E
2. I only work on open source. My income is at most half of what it would be if I worked on proprietary software. I do donate to other projects, and I do appreciate (serious) donors. I've never gotten (or asked for) tips, but I've gotten one or two donations big enough to make a difference.
3. I would also encourage you to read about how con artists (and marketers) manipulate people by generate reciprocity:
- Someone on the street hands you a "free" pamphlet / flower / etc. and asks for a donation.
- Thought leaders are sent a free product
- Managers / executives are wined and dined just below what conflict-of-interest laws allow
... and so on.
I don't appreciate being manipulated. I have turned down gifts and donations before which felt in bad faith.
Why you think that it applies here?
However, my experience is that cost structures at FAANG, Microsoft, etc. are astronomical. In abstract, if the CEO decides to donate $500k and make a blog post, things can sometimes be relatively fast and easy.
In practice, usually one person spends a few weeks or months working to make a case for it, which bounces around the reporting channels, approvals, etc. Communication about it is approved through legal and marketing. Legal brings up issues about what to do if a maintainer is in Cuba and subject to Cuban embargoes, China and subject to Chinese taxes, or the Talysh-Mughan Autonomous Republic.
Median compensation is around $350k (and total cost close to double that). Basically anything external-facing like this usually ends up costing a lot by small business standards. $500k is 0.0003% of Microsoft's annual revenues, or on the order of magnitude of the annual cost of 1 employee (or 0.0006% of the organization). At a trillion-dollar scale, it kinda makes sense to have process. A mistake can wipe out single-digit percent of stock value overnight.
My experience, also, is that the process doesn't improve quality. It just prevents stupid shit from going out.
How much more they needed to spend to make also blog post PR and other PR stuff, in addition to donations?
It's not punishment. I think everybody here would reply in the same way if someone asked a week ago "what if GitHub donated $500 to top-1000 OSS projects?"
A company gives to open source projects.
People complain about how little it is, and generate negative PR for the donation.
For a company, negative PR is a punishment.
What's the lesson here? At least the lesson some in the HN community are teaching is that if you are a big company and you donate to open source projects, you will generate negative PR for yourself.
(We can assume and/or question their motivations, but to me, motivations are almost always irrelevant to an act of generosity. Feel good about yourself if you help others out! Garner positive PR if you help others out as a company! Why should positive things for the giver detract from an act of generosity? Got a problem with the system? That's a problem with the system, not the person or company being generous.)
You're coming off as a very bitter actor, with all comments verging on trolling.
I'm sure if some other company donated $0.5M to FOSS maintainers the negativity would be greatly muted or even absent.
Microsoft uses these platforms to advertise/promote. I don't like it. Advertising and PR are pollution. If Coca-Cola PR or big oil or the tobacco industry promoted on this website, I'd have a similar distaste for it.
When you compared the payments to "blood money" I was like "Oh my", but then I recalled an article that points out that Bill Gates knew Epstein "decades prior to 2011" ( https://unlimitedhangout.com/2021/05/investigative-reports/t... ) and I throw up my hands (and my breakfast.) What a world we live in, eh?
You're a traveller in a lesser economically developed country. You're in the wilderness, you haven't seen anyone in a while. You see a stranger, who sees you're travelling alone and invites you to a meal, eager to share a part of their life with you.
Now this is how GitHub is acting:
At the end, you reach into your pocket for a note of the local currency, the stranger shakes his head.
You continue taking out a nominal amount.
"No", the stranger says in his language. You insist, putting the note into his hand. The stranger looks offended. You smile, oblivious.
"THANK YOU VERY MUCH!" You repeat and kill the stranger's act of altruism.
But I don't think it is anything more than marketing on the side of GitHub. And I think what annoys people is when people seem to think it is more than that.