While I suppose you can argue that leaves things no worse off than the current sex work landscape, it seems like any company jumping into this isn't going to look good in the public and regulatory eye if their attitude is to just keep letting customers get diseases and providers get stalked and murdered. This is why brothels work. They can actually provide security. A phone app can't.
Sex worker positive apps seem to have a challenge maintaining traction for various reasons (edit: even in jurisdictions where it’s legal).
The creators wanted to launch it in the U.S. where it is illegal, and wanted to remain anonymous.
I'm all for innovation and trying to make things safer (I think they also said they would do background checks), but I was skeptical and thought it was more likely a scam than not.