I was hoping, rather, to caution against believing anything without first examining the arguments simply because of "star appeal". Y'know, "a celebrity said it it must be true...."
One wouldn't believe scientific theories from the pulpit without thinking, so why shouldn't one be a little skeptical hearing metaphysics from a scientist?
Or at least, that's my opinion, speaking as a layman.
Thinking is thinking.
As an example, Richard Dawkins coined the term 'meme' which is a term describing a gene equivalent for social traits. 'Memetics' often ends looking at religion for various reasons (availablitlity of data for one). His focus (obsession) with religion is not incidental. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meme#Memetic_accounts_of_religi...
I know people filter ideas based upon the authority figures that approve it, but that kind of lazy evaluation should only be applied by people who do not really care and the thoughts of such people do not really matter as it is at most something they mention in conversation.
Those who do care should judge the idea on it's own merits conducting whatever research is necessary rather than calling to authority to beg for answers.
Of course, this means I agree with you! His ideas should be treated like any layman's, it's just that so should everyone else's.