Arrington's not a racist...he's just being dishonest
whydoeseverythingsuck.com
whydoeseverythingsuck.com
This seems to be a common theme (though not universal, certainly) of Hacker News and Silicon Valley as a whole: complete utter obliviousness to the world outside their bubble, and the idea that they might have advantages that other people don't. It's practically painful reading the constant Hacker News posts claiming that privilege doesn't exist, and Arrington just seems to be another source of this in the tech-world echo chamber.
Most entrepreneurs are consistently logical on technical topics, but whenever the idea comes up that maybe, just maybe, they have a lot of advantages in life that other people don't have -- that not everyone can just quit their job, learn how to program in a few weeks, and make millions on a startup -- quite a few seem to clam up. Is it that hard to comprehend that maybe Silicon Valley isn't a perfect meritocracy, and that issues of socioeconomic background, nationality, sex, race, and so forth still exist, to some extent or another, and that it's important to at least be aware of them?
Apparently it is, because any post even suggesting this seems to be downvoted to oblivion in any thread on the topic, because if we stop talking about issues, the issues will just go away.
But as the author says, being ignorant of privilege and people who don't have the same advantages that you have doesn't inherently make you racist. It just makes you ignorant, which is hardly uncommon and not difficult to fix, and certainly not worth such drama.
For instance, I (white, male, college-educated, Sagittarius) am offered a job at a hot SV startup. According to the theory of privilege, I should credit my race and background in having at least some part in that accomplishment. But how am I to know how much of the job offer was because of my "privilege" and how much was because I was actually the best candidate? Where does my privilege end and my actual talent and skill begin?
Now suppose I accept this theory. What is the expected behavior? I should turn down the offer in hopes that they will hire someone else from a less-privileged background? That strikes me as somewhat unrealistic.
On point would be to answer the question (to yourself) of what you are going to do when you are part of the hiring process for open positions at that startup, or when you are approached about mentoring, or making an angel investment, or making an introduction.
Given that you seem intent on dismissing the issue as somehow unknowable as well as concluding that the only course of action is unrealistic, my best guess is that you will happily behave consistently with your cognitive biases, rather than working around them.
That doesn't make you a racist. It just makes you ignorant, and one of a proud majority, it would appear.
I guess I'll stop reading & learn more about generator functions instead.
yaaaay productivity
I don't know exactly what MA said, but I doubt it made him look anywhere as bad as the editing did.
No one imagines him sitting around spewing racial
epithets or purposefully discriminating, or even
thinking bad racial thoughts, but that is not a very
high bar.
Orwell had it wrong. His vision of the future was, in some respects, too optimistic. For even if Arrington is innocent of thoughtcrime ("thinking bad racial thoughts"), he must still somehow be guilty of something.Thing is, these fine gradations between "racist" and "racially insensitive" may mean something to the original poster, but for the vast majority of people there is little functional difference between the two.
Zooming out from Arrington, this is what usually happens after someone prominent is accused of heretical beliefs. A lot of people come out of the woodwork to kick a man when he's down. Now Arrington may deserve it more than most (surely there's a lot of schadenfreude in the Valley now) but this sort of witch hunt could easily have been mounted against any prominent figure in tech.
There is really no defense. You can't say your friends are black. You can't point to the pipeline. You can't point out Asians. And you damn well can't mention the statistical implications of the B__l C___e, even as a hypothesis, as it will drive the neo-Puritans into a hissing rage and convince them that you "just don't get it".
All they want you to do is confess to your sins in a struggle session. Even if you've never been "thinking bad racial thoughts", that is not enough for them. Nothing ever is.