Supreme Court limits EPA authority to set power plant climate standards
cnbc.com
cnbc.com
Isn't that agency the EPA?
This ruling makes no sense. If the EPA cannot enforce environmental protection measures, because the consequences might affect other industries, then we may as well dismantle every federal agency out there.
This is not about EPA enforcement of a congressional regulation. This is about the EPA both inventing the regulation and then doing the enforcement of it. Specifically about a large scale impacting regulations and then enforcing. If Congress mandated environmental guidelines that must be met in a timetable and enacted those regulations for the EPA to enforce the supreme Court would have held that as okay. The EPA is not acting with clear delegation from the representative body.
This doesn't make much sense either.
Agencies administrators are usually appointed by elected representatives as matter experts. Under the assumption that actions cannot be taken by experts chosen by elected representatives, we should gut every single federal agency out there.
The executive branch exist to enforce the laws not to create them doesn't matter how expert their administrators are. They don't exist to create the law.
Separation of powers.
There is a reason why the legislative branch gave the executive branch the power to regulate that. That is subject matter experts which are not interested in party politics do a better job at keeping up with relevant research.
In this case, the job of reducing emissions from power plants was given to the EPA. They have been doing that job for some years, but recently they decided to go beyond their authority and require operators of coal plants to produce less electricity. The operators would only be allowed to generate more electricity if they built or bought solar or wind generation capacity instead.
The Supreme Court has ruled that Congress never gave them the authority to do that. They can require an operator to install filters and scrubbers that reduce the amount of pollution that they produce, but they cannot require them to serve fewer customers.
Imagine if the FDA showed up at your favorite restaurant and told them that they were only allowed to serve 70% of their current customers, unless they served Hungarian borsht to the other 30%.
Now it might be a good idea to burn less coal. Coal power has killed more people than any other source, iirc. We should replace all the coal plants with nuclear, in my opinion. But Congress never gave the EPA that job. Only Congress can do that job, or decide to delegate it to an agency. The EPA cannot unilaterally decide to take on any task they want merely because it seems like a good idea. They have to do the tasks Congress gave them, and nothing else.
Thank you for having a sane take on this. I hate how the media is trying to frame it as an environmental issue when it's actually a governmental power issue.
If our elected officials want to give the executive branch that power they need to get to work and pass those laws.
> Imagine if the FDA showed up at your favorite restaurant and told them that they were only allowed to serve 70% of their current customers, unless they served Hungarian borsht to the other 30%.
I do not get the borsht part. If the FDA had the task to reduce diabetics and science shows it needs stop the creation of new diabetics by 20xx. If we knew that a certain food chains menu causes diabetics at disproportionate rate (and there is no way to reduce that that restaurant can stay up after 20xx because thermodynamics) so that those goals would be reachable only by reducing that share in the market why can't the FDA enforce a diabetics creation rate limit by limiting the amount of diabetes causing food at worst diabetes creators under the mandate educe diabetics? I think that's what they do. That they have an additional incentive that selling low diabetic food increases the quota for selling high diabetics food, doesn't change that they are still reducing total diabetics creation rate.
What if a competing restraunt paid off the people in govt to put this company out of business?
What about other other competing interests besides the FDAs mission?
There's a bunch of real life questions here. As long as humans are involved it's never as black and white as: this causes X do we can shut it down with no other complications.
There processes in involving pressure from domain experts. There are processes within the executive branch to address those. If those fail the legislative branch can update those process. It that fails the legislative branch can intervene with in that specific issue with new legislation. Counter question: What makes you think the supreme court is even vaguely qualified to settle whether science is questionable?
> What if a competing restraunt paid off the people in govt to put this company out of business?
We have legal procedures for that that don't involve the supreme court. Even the tobacco industry eventually fell to that.
> What about other other competing interests besides the FDAs mission?
There are processes with in a republic to fix that.
> There's a bunch of real life questions here.
Yes and they have been solved well enough for ages.
> As long as humans are involved it's never as black and white as: this causes X do we can shut it down with no other complications.
Literally no-one claims that. But what is claimed that if the consequences are weight turning of coal looks a lot less black then leaving coal running.
Humans being involved in anything are why a legal system exists.
Sure, along with other undesirable effects. But just as it is a mistake to decide what authority they have based on just their name, it would also be a mistake to do so based on just a one–sentence summary. We really should be quoting out of the enabling legislation.
Suffice to say that this legislation is long and complex, but it specifically gives the EPA the authority to mandate design improvements to new power plants (prior to construction) so that they will operate at the best possible efficiency, and also the authority to mandate the installation of new systems to reduce the pollution put out by both existing plants and new ones. This has historically been things like scrubbers to remove pollutants from the waste stream. Think of new hardware devices that you can add to a plant or a factory that reduce the pollution while maintaining their function.
The EPA tried to argue that they had devised a “system” under the meaning of the law that allowed them to shift power generation from coal to gas or renewable power. The Court pointed out that this would gut the word of all useful meaning, and that it would give the EPA the power to unilaterally decide the entire industrial policy of the country. They would be able to use the same language to simply ban almost anything they wanted, and it’s pretty clear that Congress never intended that. The EPA could use that new authority to reduce pollution by banning virtually all industrial activity, causing it all to be done in other countries, for example.
There is another interesting aspect of the enabling legislation. It requires the EPA to investigate multiple systems that achieve the goal of reducing some specific pollutant from some specific source (such as soot from a power plant or whatever), then to determine how much reduction the best of those systems would achieve. Then instead of mandating that everyone has to install that specific system, they are allowed to mandate that everyone must achieve the same reduction by some means. This gives the operators a chance to beat the EPA on either cost or performance, and avoids forced mistakes. If the EPA accidentally selects the second–best system rather than the best, nobody is forced to use a sub–par means of reducing the pollutant.
However, in the case of the EPA’s new generating–shifting “system”, everybody would be required to participate in the same way for it to work. The opinion states: “By contrast, and by design, there is no control a coal plant operator can deploy to attain the emissions limits established by the Clean Power Plan.”
You should at least read the six–page syllabus to the opinion: https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/21pdf/20-1530_n758.pdf
Very interesting link, thank you.
I don't want the legislative branch to pass ANY laws.
We literally have too many laws to count already.
I want the FDA to EDUCATE people about the new dangerous chemical and THATS IT.
Let people read the literature or put a warning on the box and let the free market decide.
A quite naive take.
We would still be covering our houses with asbestos and adding lead to gasoline, if we let the _people_ decide individually what to do.
Treat people like children and let the government decide what's best for them.
</s>That's always worked out great</s>
I prefer treating people like adults and letting them make their own decisions and keeping the government around to educate people not to control them.
In a world where corporations would rather literally kill their customers in order to generate gains for their shareholders, saying that regulations are put in place to "control" citizens, is the obvious naive take.
There are hundreds of examples of corporations choosing profit over humanity, famously recent ones are the opioid crisis and climate change. Let me know how you would fix these issues with just "education".
Climate change = media generated: it's been way hotter on earth that it is today in the earths history. Were actually at one of the cooler times in earths history, in between ice ages.
https://www.climate.gov/news-features/climate-qa/whats-hotte...
> where corporations would rather literally kill their customers in order to generate gains for their shareholders
Killing your customers seems like a poor economic decision.
If it is important for the EPA to act on these matters, then call your Congress critters and have them pass a law granting more power to the EPA.
This ruling is a win for democracy and the rule of law.
Relying on novel interpretations of law like this is fragile, and short sighted. It's worth it to get everyone on board instead of trying to pull a fast one. In a democracy, getting everyone on board means getting laws passed.
It is telling that just this particular iteration of the Supreme Court decided that the EPA lacked this regulatory authority; as early as 2007 a conservative Supreme Court ruled CO2 was a pollutant and compelled the Bush Administration to regulate it as such, even though EPA at the time was loathe to do so, leaving no doubt the power of the EPA to regulate.
The EPA's regulatory authority was only ever a question worthy of raising when the Supreme Court's composition changed; conservative judicial radicalism was normalized, hence the ruling. There was no deeper principle behind this ruling.
If the EPA needs more authority, Congress will.have to pass a law amending it's charter.