I never understood why native English speakers use Sahara and desert and think they are different things. Sometimes they even say "Sahara desert".
I never understood why native English speakers use Sahara and desert and think they are different things. Sometimes they even say "Sahara desert".
Near me, there's the Sonoran desert and the Great Basin desert. If I lived in eastern Asia I might think of the Gobi desert. There's many deserts. So while I take your point that 'Sahara', in a non-English language, denotes what I call in English 'desert', I would say that the phrase 'Sahara desert' could be interpreted to signify "the place on this planet, that could be characterized as having a desert ecosystem, that is described by the people who live nearby as 'Sahara'". For the people who do not know that 'Sahara' is used by some other people to denote what they think of when they say the word 'desert', the word 'desert' is not extraneous. But for you, who does, it is.
I understand that... but Sahara means the latter in Arabic. Any desert is Sahara.
Languages are littered with these kind of things. Like every language.
It is just a small observation actually, not a big deal.
My adjacent point is that this is very common: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_tautological_place_nam...
صحراء - Sahra' - Desert
الصحراء الكبرى - alsahra' alkubraa - The big desert?
What language are you coming from?
They speak English, not Arabic or Hindi, and those words haven’t been turned into loan words. Likely, because English has its own equivalent.