That being said, it looks like we average around 4 regional bank failures a year in the US. There are a little under 5000 banks in the US, almost all of which are regional, so that leaves a 0.08% chance that any particular one of them will fail (all things being equal, which they probably aren't).
A bank like Chase has all sorts of fees and minimums for a simple checking account - which a normal regional bank doesn't.
What's the benefit to an a average person of banking with a subsidiary of a huge Wall Street bank? They don't even want your business. The only reason they are even offering consumer services is because of out of control empire building, like how JP Morgan bought Chase Manhattan.
You don't have to bank with a national brand name.
You don't have to pay a monthly fee for checking.
You don't have to have a monthly direct deposit.
You don't have to have a $1500 minimum balance (like with Chase).
And credit unions are fine of course, but banks have free checking too.
I wonder if there are a lot of people who think you will get food poisoning from any hamburger not made at a McDonald's.
There are service providers that cater to the 99% that spare them from totally reinventing the wheel. There's a company headquartered near me, that you never heard of, that as I recall basically provides a white-label e-commerce platform to small and mid-size businesses.
A particularly fucked up website, I would bet is likely the product of a business that did have some in-house tech people years ago, and once they had something working, has prudently avoided redoing it from scratch.
I have a piece of equipment that I financed through Bank of Colorado. They're not even that small a bank, but I have a different account to pay my loan every month than I have to see my balance on the loan...it is not great.
People only really care that their money is safe and accessible, and in that sense banking is pretty boring.
That doesn't at all follow just from the fact that a list of failed banks included many, many more smaller regional banks than larger banks:
1. I'm assuming there ARE a lot more smaller, regional banks than large banks, so you'd expect them to be the majority of a list of failed banks.
2. The failure of a single large bank affects many more customers and a lot more money than a single small bank failure.
3. It's pretty clear that large banks in the "too big to fail" category will get institutional and government support (e.g. the government even operates a "systemically important financial institutions" list), while smaller banks will be allowed to fail. While that may mean your money is safer in a larger institution, it's not really because "regional banks are much more likely to practice poor risk management and fail than larger banks".
It is, actually, from a customer perspective; the FDIC comes in, replaces management, and employs the staff as temporary employees of the FDIC to keep things running smoothly. For an average customer (if they're under the $250k threshold), they come in the next business day and conduct business as usual.
https://www.npr.org/2009/03/26/102384657/anatomy-of-a-bank-t...
Second, there are over 4,000 banks in the US. The fact that fewer than 0.1% fail per year is actually a really strong argument on how much safer banks are.
And finally that those few that did fail were insured by the US govt is the icing on the cake.
None of this was true for crypto over the past few years.
*As long as whole is less than $250k.
In the case of WaMu in 2008 for instance, the OTS took possession of the bank and sold it to JPMorgan Chase. They didn't draw on the deposit insurance fund and everyone stayed whole. [1]
"According to FDIC spokeswoman LaJuan Williams-Young, 'No depositor has ever lost a penny of insured deposits since the FDIC was created in 1933.'" [2, 3]
[edit] Looks like I found one case where a bank failed and a total of $500,000 in uninsured deposits (not in a single account, in total) were forfeit. [4]
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Washington_Mutual
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Deposit_Insurance_Corp...
[3] https://www.magnifymoney.com/banking/deposits-bank-failures/
[4] https://www.depositaccounts.com/blog/bank-failures/#p21332
There is a problem with large banks. It’s the same problem with large companies from any other industry. They gain oversized political power.
However, it’s weird to me how much we go after the banks for being large when it’s far more regulated than nearly every other industry in the country.
This is just a truism because all insured deposits are insured, and all non-insured deposits are non—insured.
IIRC this happened at least once during the eurozone crisis where national deposit schemes could not insure the cross-border activities of their banks.
FDIC is required to go with the resolution that will cost the least to the fund. An acquirer offering to take on all Deposits rather than just insured deposits is typically not a big problem for the acquirer, and can save a surprising amount of money on the FDICs side, so most acquisition offers tend to be for all deposits rather than just insured deposits. (It also tends to keep your new customers happier if they did not lose money, which is very much an actual consideration that goes into bidding on a failing bank).
However, sometimes a bank will successfully bid for only the insured portions of deposit accounts. This happened with The Enloe State Bank in 2019, where Legend Bank's bid to acquire just the insured portions of deposit accounts.
Nevertheless, losing deposits over the insured amount in a bank closure is definitely the exception and not the norm in recent times.
Until we found out that one guy had done the wrong thing and corrupted a file a few months ago. That's how we found out our backups (made with the very expensive backup software Alexandria) didn't work. And this was well before Git, so we didn't have multiple redundant repositories we could sync from to recover. The humongous NetApp rackmount RAID was 35 gigabytes if I recall correctly.
This is a problem with improving reliability through redundancy: sometimes instead of getting reliability, you just shift the failure modes to more catastrophic systemic failures, because they happen too rarely for people to assess the risks properly.
Speaking of systemic failures, everybody who's had US$10k in the bank since last year (or in other dollar-denominated assets such as T-bills) has lost US$800 of it to inflation over the last year. What else could you have you spent US$800 on? If your retirement fund has US$100k in the money market that inflation cost you US$8000.
Still, be glad you're not in Argentina. Our central bank printed a trillion pesos last month, a quarter of the monetary base, and the inflation over the last year has been about 60%.
If that's a concern to you, put it in I Bonds; interest tracks inflation, so the current rate is 9.62%. Buy $15k a year, or $30k if you've a spouse.
The government here also indexed a lot of things to inflation: pensions, certain bonds, etc. So when they couldn't pay their debts about 20 years ago they started falsifying the official inflation rate. Poof, no more problem! What do you think the US government will do with I bonds if it's insolvent? It'll default, sneakily or openly.
You can't reduce the risks of systemic failure by centralizing harder. To manage risk you need to diversify, not double down.
First off, there's a big difference between a government collapsing and a government defaulting on its debt. And falsifying the inflation statistics doesn't even officially count as defaulting on debt.
Second, even if a government collapses, ammo and MREs are probably not a great investment. Did you find it useful to invest in ammo and MREs when the Burmese government collapsed? Probably not if you're not in Burma. Do you think Ukrainians in Mariupol who invested in ammo and MREs are the ones who are in good shape? How about the Iraqis who stocked up before the US invasion? No, the people who are in good shape there are the ones who left ahead of time.
I can tell you that Argentines who invested in ammo and MREs when we defaulted on our sovereign debt didn't end up any better off. Worse off in some cases, because their arsenals got them raided by the police. Some of them wrote entertaining heavily fictionalized blogs, but they didn't come out better off. People who left and people who organized their communities came out pretty okay.
So, let's forget about your adolescent Rambo fantasies and refocus on realistic hedges against systemic failure and hyperinflation. Because I can tell you from experience that living through it can suck pretty bad, but diversifying can help a lot.
It's hard to imagine a more unrealistic approach to financial planning than yours. It's up there with Charlie Manson's plan to hide in a hole in the desert until all the other white people were killed in a race war prophesied through Beatles songs.
Back in the 2007-2010 financial crisis, IndyMac Bank went under. They were a major bank on the west coast, especially the Los Angeles metro area.
And when they did, there were thousands of depositors who were over the FDIC limits for their accounts, which at the time were only $100,000 per account, not yet raised to $250,000 per account. Some were individuals, some were businesses, some were trust accounts, some were only supposed to be temporarily over the limit because they held money from a deceased person that was a life insurance payout or going through probate, and so on.
But what was really unusual in their case was that the FDIC could not find any other bank that would take over IndyMac Bank directly, and assume its debts and deposits.
So the FDIC had to create a brand new bank out of whole cloth, called IndyMac Federal Bank (note the name), to take over IndyMac Bank, before it could be dealt with further. Eventually it got acquired by One West.
Just this one bank's failure cost the FDIC eleven billion dollars. And the FDIC as an agency barely managed to stay afloat during the 2007-2010 financial crisis, because it had so many banks where it had to either manage shotgun weddings with other more-stable banks, or bail them out entirely. Of course, the FDIC had an implicit backstop from Congress, but they came damn near bumping up against their full budget during this time period.
And again, that eleven billion for that one bank was not counting all the people who were over their deposit limits -- $270 million over the limits, in total. Those people were screwed.
https://www.latimes.com/archives/blogs/money-company/story/2...
(And as 'arcticbull mentioned: the FDIC has reliably made much larger account holders whole.)
Usually, no
As an insurer, sure, $250K per account owner per ownership class. (Notably, single and joint accounts are separate ownership categories, so with proper distribution of balances, a married couple with single and joint accounts at one institution, is covered up to $1,000,000 in total. $250k each in the individual category, and $250k each in the joint category.
But it also acts as a receiver of failed banks, and in that capacity can facilitate the sale of assets tied to the uninsured portion of the debts represented by account balances. Usually, this ends up with making account holders whole without limit.
Insurance limits are not by account, they are by account ownership category. Checking and savings account held as single accounts are all part of the same ownership category:
https://www.fdic.gov/resources/deposit-insurance/brochures/d...
("A lot" of cities is also doing a lot of work in that sentence... 250k is 20% of 1.25M. That would buy you a lot of house in the vast majority of US cities.