Free iPhone pits premium brand against Android
sfgate.com
sfgate.com
[1] Prices are not actual, but are close to what I recall when I last signed up on a contract.
To get the iPhone 3GS for 1€ from Deutsche Telekom you have to sign their 60€ contract for 24 months. That’s 1,440€. The same contract costs 50€ without a phone, that’s 1,200€ for 24 months or 240€ less.
It’s not really worth it buying the 3GS new and unlocked from Apple (if you want that specific contract) since they want 370€ from you. It usually never is worth it, no matter the carrier. (That is, if those carriers offer a subsidized iPhone. Some MVNOs don’t, but you might still get away cheaper by picking a MVNO and buying the unlocked phone. MVNOs are often cheap and might have contracts that fit your needs better.)
But there is always a difference in price between getting a contract with phone and one without. Some carriers don’t add to the price of the contract but let you pay for the phone in installments. In practice, though, that’s a small difference. (The nice thing about paying in installments is that the installments automatically stop. Your contract will cost you the same increased price, even after 24 months. You have to manually intervene if you want to pay less.)
What you definitely should never do is buy your phone based on the subsidized price. That just makes no sense. You always have to consider the whole package. Deutsche Telekom offers a 20€ contract (30 minutes for outgoing calls, unlimited incoming calls, 0.19€ per SMS, unlimited data, throttled to GPRS speeds when you are over 300MB) and if that’s all you need you have to pay 480€ for two years of contract and 200€ for the 3GS. That’s less than half of the 1,440€ for the 1€ 3GS.
(I’m sorry, I’m currently researching phone contracts for my sister so I have all this crap stuck in my head.)
As other commenters have mentioned, this is usually not the case outside the US. For example, Vodafone UK offers both different plan prices AND handset prices depending on length of contract.
As an example of the power of "free*", my mom went to buy one of her employees an iPhone and told me in amazement how it was the first time she walked out of an AT&T store without spending a dime. I'm sure I'm not the only one she's told the story to, and I don't think she was as excited about the time when she bought my grandmother a $50 3GS just a few months ago.
In comparison, let's say you get a Samsung Android phone from Boost Mobile (which uses Sprint's network). That costs $150. But Boost's monthly unlimited plan is $55/month. So the plan cost over 2 years would be $1320. Add the phone and you're at $1470. So going the Android route on the same network would be $930 cheaper.
But "free (with contract)" is a powerful marketing device, and as a result any points made in reference to it are likely to stand.
I can get a Samsung Galaxy S2 right now, for $99 and a contract. That thing will run circles around that old iPhone. This is a marketing ploy, nothing more. Is it any wonder the global economy is in shambles when people can't determine what's free and what is "free"?
As an iOS dev I'm a little sad that I'm going to have to keep that low a common denominator in mind for the next few years though.
Or cable boxes. I assume that you have a top of the line TiVO rather than using what the cable company offers? Cause the upfront cost of the TiVo box is dwarfed by your long term cable bill.
Some people just have different priorities.
I've never thought cable was worth the money so I can't say if a similar logic applies there.
My 3GS is still running fine, altho slowly with iOS5. It will last me until the iPhone 5.
1. for over 12 months big US carriers have been offering free androids with 2 years contract signon.
2. Samsung has the top selling smartphone in the US despite 4s numbers..
3. iphone release and Jobs dies.
The article is lacking in logic and few other points
The iPhone 3GS is still a very capable device anyway.