> the companies grew by delivering what the military wanted, then gradually it became “your so good at giving us what we want, we’ll just let you sort it all out, just make sure it can do XYZ” … and thus the disconnect grows with the users now mostly cut out of the design loop except for limited feedback towards the end of “product development”
For what it's worth, the counterpoint: Government-led purchases of military products have led to colossal cluster-fucks like the F-35 where everyone and their dog seems to have been allowed to specify inputs and throw around stuff mid-project, throwing everything off course. Here in Germany, the same issue has been blamed on virtually all of our military purchase scandals and issues.
In contrast, Rheinmetall just presented their new KF51 Panther tank [1] which they developed fully on their own as a response to the Russian T-14 Armata, which means it is expected to be in serial production in 2024-2025 while the "collaboration project" KNDS (between French Nexter, Krauss-Maffei Wegmann and Rheinmetall) is expected to be in production in 2035. This fits into Chancellor Scholz' recent announcement of a Zeitenwende in military investment, of which a huge part will be to buy what the industry already has ready and tested instead of wasting time and money on bespoke solutions.
[1] https://www.t-online.de/nachrichten/deutschland/militaer-ver...