Markus Frind: "Do VC Backed Founders Actually Make Any Money?"
plentyoffish.wordpress.com
plentyoffish.wordpress.com
What he doesn't seem to get is that some startups actually cost a lot to start. Loopt, for example, could not have been built without VC scale money. If you want to do something like that (or Google), you need millions. And if you succeed, you end up rich. Ending up with 10% of the company is not so bad if the company is worth a billion dollars.
Also, his statistics are junk. That "government report" showing that most small businesses are still in operation after 4 years has nothing to do with startups. The small businesses they're talking about are plumbers and shoe shops. The success rate is lower for startups. Which makes sense, because the payoff, if the company succeeds, is much higher.
He was a single founder, and he did everything himself... which is better phrased as 'everything that got done, he did'.
He didn't have any plan or roadmap; he went along and did what he wanted to, and it worked out well.
Much (most?) of his revenue comes from Google AdSense, which has not been as generous to many other who have chosen it as their primary source of revenue (this is largely helped by his site being lower on resources (some pictures and a lot of text), instead of media intensive).
Doing what you want is a good way to make macro decisions. Should I try to be a dentist or a programmer? I like programming, I'll do that. Unless your psychological makeup is perfect, it doesn't do quite as well for micro decisions. Should I eat that chocolate cake? Well, I want to. Should I go to work today? Nah, I'm tired. Should I drink that next beer? Why the hell not?
I guess it comes down to that I should have been clearer in drawing the distinctions I was trying to make.
For example, if funding reduces your 100% ownership to 25% (x = 0.25), then you'll have to multiply the value of your company by 4 (1/.25) to end up with the same valuation. If you think funding will push you beyond the 4x, then it's a good deal.
This goes directly against what I've heard before: "a small piece of a big pie is better than a large piece of nothing."
I'm certain that for a lot of these people, their advice is not exactly scientific, but more along the lines of "I did this and this and this, and it all worked out", which is fine, but in a complex system like that, who knows what caused what, and what is just noise.
One of the things I liked about 'Founders at Work' was that it was such a wide array of people and undertakings, that it did actually give some insight into things that were common to othewise diverse groups.
but I think what he is getting at, is that to be successful in a start-up you don't really need vc money. there are plenty of other ways to do it. Start-ups are too obsessed with funding. You hear about start-ups building products no way as complicated as loopt and yet they are getting 5 million. What are they spending it on!?! The fact of the matter is, many start-ups will not be profitable even with a seemingly good idea and vc money to propel them. I get the sense that a lot of the funding craze is an attempt to stave off bankruptcy, nothing more.