What I learned from trying to hang Socrates
1517.substack.com
1517.substack.com
"In the event, friends, followers, and students encouraged Socrates to flee Athens, an action which the citizens expected; yet, on principle, Socrates refused to flout the law and escape his legal responsibility to Athens (see: Crito). Therefore, faithful to his teaching of civic obedience to the law, the 70-year-old Socrates executed his death sentence and drank the hemlock, as condemned at trial. (See: Phaedo)."
The arguments end with this:
"And Socrates was wise enough to give his life for it. He had ample opportunity to escape. But he threw himself into this bonfire of psychic incongruity to give one last gift to his fellow Athenians. This sacrifice is, perhaps, Socrates' greatest contribution to his beloved Athens."
I did not know any of that, but I only read the Symposium.
"Maximus also references(1), via rumor, that Socrates most likely stood mute and defiant at the trial, facing down his accusers."
I think the people genuinely thought Socrates' ideas corrupted the youth and indirectly gave birth to the Tyrants. But we may never know.
There are many overlapping possibilities that aren't necessarily incompatible. For example, over here, the Girard's conceptualization of the scapegoat isn't incompatible with your perspective. It's important for the community involved in the process to genuinely believe that the scapegoat is guilty. And, if you look at the timeline, this trial (and others that we may not know about) helped to restore Athens to relative stability.
As I've argued, there's good indication that some of his ideas may have indeed influenced his students to commit treasonous acts. The list of his former students who went on to either overthrow the Athenian government or defect to Sparta is quite long. It's possible that there's something there. But there is a general consensus that he, generally, didn't advocate for it. In Plato's and Xenephon's dialogues he explicitly advocated harmony with the laws of the polis. And Plato posits that one of the reasons why he chose to stay was because of this belief.
That being said, I also think that the Athenians wanted to get rid of him, they didn't want to actually kill him. Usually, in ancient Athens, punishments were carried out in a day or two of their delivery. But due to a festival and other reasons, his punishment wasn't carried out for more than a month and he had plenty of means and opportunity to escape. Socrates was the one who refused to leave. He, for the lack of a better phrase, committed suicide by jury.
There was a famous saying that I remember, "a translation of a poem is like a woman: if she is pretty, she is not faithful, and if she is faithful, she is not pretty."
A thousand pardons for the inherent misogyny; it is not intentional.
...and I thought it was John Ciardi.
https://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/yevgeny_yevtushenko_39131...
But the fuller story makes so much more sense.
So this is about a fucking role playing game. This story and every comment here is about not Socrates. Not anything at all meaningful. But a role playing game.
At least from what I see, it was an actual RPG and not a goddamned CRPG! And that is a miracle for HN.
The comments here are children raging about never knowing one of the widest-broadcast thinkers in human history. Which is apropos . . .
The idea is to use Socratic arguments and debates as if we were the characters to explore Plato's Republic. And it was really fun! It was historically semi-accurate, well informed, and we had discussions afterwards.
It's about what I uncovered arguing against them as Socrates' prosecutor. As I was arguing against someone who literally taught this at a university, I ended up reading two books in the process and a few papers.
This piece is the product of that. It examines how little we know about the trial and then presents the two hypotheses – the one I argued to convict him and one in his defense.
If you take the time to read the piece, you'll see that every argument is well sourced and covers a fairly comprehensive gamut of thinking on the topic.