I’m not sure to what extent it constituted financial crime versus just being an ethical grey zone, and the book is of course not without its share of criticism, but it was certainly an enjoyable read.
I’m not sure to what extent it constituted financial crime versus just being an ethical grey zone, and the book is of course not without its share of criticism, but it was certainly an enjoyable read.
From someone who used to be in the industry, there are lots of things to complain about, and HFTs engage in lots of unfair practices (eg PFOF). Michael Lewis doesn't understand them or what they are.
As an example, I once A/B tested interactive brokers vs robinhood on their execution quality. With notional volumes of a few thousand dollars per trade, the IB commission was very much worth it compared to the poor execution quality from RH.
The issue is that many consumers don't understand that a free brokerage can actually be more expensive for them than a more expensive brokerage.
All brokers are obligated to fill orders within the National Best Bid Offer spread. A retail trader can't get a better price on the open market.
> As an example, I once A/B tested interactive brokers vs robinhood on their execution quality.
IB sells retail orders to market makers too. This has more to do with Robinhood being awful than with PFOF being detrimental by itself.
Also, IB tells you where your orders go - you can see if they went to a PFOF vendor or some other venue. You can also decide where to route your order, although this costs a bit of money.
However, wouldn't it be fair to say that the underlying problem is not PFOF (which does seem to benefit small retail customers), but market microstructure, and specifically the issue of order routing, and that there is not one market place, but many (many of which are "dark")?
If I were to design markets, I'd seriously consider:
- obligation to trade on one central exchange
- a Tobin tax (ie a minuscule tax on all transactions)
- not continuous trading with a LOB, but an auction approximately every 5 minutes or so with stochastic cutoff time
* Remove reg NMS as it applies to brokers and broker-dealers, allowing them to trade anywhere they want. Keep the requirement that brokers must give a price to customers at or better than the NBBO (but let them trade how they want on the exchanges). This should make brokerage fees cheaper and reduce spreads.
* Require brokers to provide execution quality reports to the public the way that brokerage fees are reported to the public. Brokers would then have to say: "$0 commissions, 0.1% average spreads" or something along those lines. The market for high-fee high-quality brokers would likely develop around that: "$5 commissions, 0.01% spreads" is compelling to people who trade large blocks. Hedge funds and big money traders already test brokers like this.
* Allow and/or require crossing auctions for retail market orders that get to an exchange. Privileging retail orders on exchange and having brokerages advertise their slippage should give "high-commission, low-spread" brokerages the incentive to send most customer orders to an exchange, and a mechanism to get the best possible price from the broader market.
Also, a tiny Tobin tax does currently exist - it funds the SEC. However, adding higher transaction taxes has been tried in Europe, and turned some exchanges into wastelands.
Robinhood then did away with the commission, but pocketed the PFOF, offering consumers a worse price.
Thus: retail consumers with very small orders would be better off at Robinhood, but with even orders of a few thousand dollars it would have been advantageous to go with a small fixed fee, but execute with a better price.
(Note that all of the above is within the NBBO, but that is not a tight benchmark, apparently.)
It's not obvious why this would result in larger spreads. The reason for it is to be able to offer smaller spreads due to lower risk.
I agree with this comment, my question is whether anyone is obligated to inform people of this. If you are an adult and have the resources to be investing in stocks, you ought to at least recognize that nothing in life is "free."
As someone with experience of markets microstructure, the book was interesting/insightful and definitely not "utterly without merit".
The book should have some sort of "paid advertisement" disclosure.
It is interesting how your opinion seems to be anyone who is critical of this book "works for HFT's"?
If you liked reading Lewis check out this book from 1932. Ivar Kreuger tried to buy up all the match factories in the world and create a monopoly for himself.