Anyone can invent characters whenever they want, and it's only a question of them sticking or not.
I think this is also one of the reasons for the Chinese tendency to push for unification and uniformity.
Anyone can invent characters whenever they want, and it's only a question of them sticking or not.
I think this is also one of the reasons for the Chinese tendency to push for unification and uniformity.
Sometimes it’s mashing two previously unrelated ‘words’ together (aka the tons of compound characters in Chinese), other times it’s coming up with something completely new.
Same rules apply though, if it doesn’t add value worth the trouble (or get mandated by the powers that be), it’ll eventually just die out or be a curiosity.
Also, to keep it tech related:
RISC = English CISC/VLIW = Chinese?
More complex characters require more education to understand is my guess. Some of the traditional ones are….. obscure, and crazy complex.
A good historical example is all the strangly specific words for groups of animals. A history I read of this indicated these terms were first found in books sold to nobility, and they were just made up. But you weren't hip if you weren't reading that literature.
One of my favorite features of the language is the fact that every element in the periodic table gets its own character - and the characters have radicals that indicate their usual state of matter (钅 for metal, 石 for non-metal solids, 氵 for liquids, 气 for gases) - see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_elements_in_East_Asia....
There are also lots of specific words for species of trees (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radical_75) and other plants (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radical_140), but characters under those radicals also include botanical terms, medicines, things made of wood and plants, etc.
Yep! For example, the most common Chinese term for "Internet" is 因特网. This is composed of three characters:
互: "mutual"
联: "join", "coupled", "allied"
网: "net" -- carrying both the meaning of a woven net and a computer network
Despite all it’s problems, the fact these two messages ‘just worked’ is really awesome. I heart Unicode, despite all that.
That's not how it works. Most Chinese characters stem from a character C having a pronunciation A referring to a meaning M being used to note another word of meaning M' with same pronunciation A (sometimes slightly different A'). This of course doesn't scale really well, hence the existence of determiners in logographic scripts, which are words used without their pronunciations placed before or after another to give a semantic clue. The innovation of Chinese (which I think is why it's still an efficient script today) was to incorporate the determiner in the character itself to give birth to a character C' where a part refer to the pronunciation and another acts as the determiner, instead of padding the main text with (a lot of) determiners.
I think character proliferation in CJK languages are a result of each word having its own character. The proliferation isn't fundamentally a proliferation of characters, it's a proliferation of words, which happens all the time in all languages. But only in certain languages does this proliferation of words result in additional characters being added to the language.
There is a fundamental difference between pictographic languages where glyphs have intrinsic meaning, and alphabetic languages where letters reflect sounds.
Old English was much better spelled than current English because it didn't have a spelling. People wrote what they heard. The current mess is because we have 5 centuries of bad standards that can render ghoti as fish. I think you'll agree that the digraph ti, as in nation, is just as nonsensical as sh for the same sound and we'd be much better served by a single glyph for both.
We in fact have that already: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Phonetic_Alphabe... English uses somewhere around 45 of those sounds depending on accent. Th for example renders two distinct sounds: ð and θ. þ is not any better than th, apart from brevity, because it also rendered to ð or θ when spoken depending on context.
Chinese is of course as much a pictographic language as English is an alphabetic one. A substantial number of glyphs come from combinations of simpler glyphs which have the same sound as the word you're trying to write.