Does smart mean internet connected? I guess I'm impressed if they have 40% market penetration. But the behaviour of having a default time to turn on describes pretty much every timer based thermostat. One of the big sales pitches of 'smart' thermostats was that thermostats with timers were too hard for normal people to set up and so their potential gains went unused. So if people are literally reducing their energy usage during the night as a result of 'smart' thermostats then that's a good thing.
Ah, you don't have to read beyond the abstract to see how it's been misrepresented:
> We find that despite lowering overall energy consumption
Lets just pause a moment and take in the full impact of that opener....
> smart thermostat control algorithms can severely increase the winter peak heating demand through load synchronization during the early morning hours, when solar energy is unavailable.
Note the use of the word can and peak here. And that it says elsewhere that wind is available at this time.
And the solution they propose, is to make the thermostats 'smarter' with regard to carbon intensity and predicted supply/demand which is the whole reason for having a smart thermostat connected to the internet in the first place.
Vague negative lies about anything that stops fossil fuels getting burnt is a real weird feature of our current society. It's like you've offended someone's god or something by suggesting burning less of an expensive poison is a good thing.
This is their open source code btw: https://github.com/zlee406/smart-heat