"If a fairly good hacker is worth $80,000 a year at a big company, then a smart hacker working very hard without any corporate bullshit to slow him down should be able to do work worth about $3 million a year."
I am not sure though that it is false. It is just not very well defined. (I don't know what it means. What actionable advice can be concluded from it.) You say wealth is different than money. This implies that wealth cannot be measured with the money you can gain from it. But you somehow measure wealth with money. You somehow convert between the two using the ratio used at big companies.
What can be said in my opinion is this:
At a big company you are paid 100.000 per year to improve someone else's huge shitty code. You are paid to fight with buerocracy. You are paid well for it.
In a small company you are paid to create new programs fast. Much faster than in big companies. But this small company either has huge risks or have much smaller income than the big company. You programming does not worth more just because you can create more lines of code or nicer code. Your programming here also worth only $100.000
Maybe I misunderstood you, but I read you as you stated that the expected value of the earning of a programmer founded startup is 36x$80.000
I think it is more close to 2x$80.000 The 2 multiplier comes from you work 2x more time in a week.
But of course I have no data to back it up.
It sounds like what you're saying is that although you may be able to get code written (and thus wealth created) faster in a small company, you don't automatically get paid in proportion.
If that's what you're saying, I agree, and in fact I said so later in the same essay:
"The other catch is that the payoff is only on average proportionate to your productivity. There is, as I said before, a large random multiplier in the success of any company. So in practice the deal is not that you're 30 times as productive and get paid 30 times as much. It is that you're 30 times as productive, and get paid between zero and a thousand times as much. If the mean is 30x, the median is probably zero."
> If you wanted to get rich, how would you do it? I think your best bet would be to start or join a startup. That's been a reliable way to get rich for hundreds of years.
Startups are not a reliable way to get rich. Or what failure rate would you still consider reliable?
That said, I do agree that working at a startup can mean that you can contribute more. That is not always the case however. Just like smart technology is leverage, a big company is leverage too. Even assuming that you'll be 36x less productive at a big company, you'll probably reach 36x more users simply because you're working on a product by a big company.
For this equality to hold:
E(Wall Street hacker's earnings) == E(startup founder's earnings)
you need an extremely high payoff, since E(startup founder's earnings) == P(startup success) * payoff of startup.
and we know the probability of success at a startup is low.Everyone on HN needs to be honest with themselves: this kind of high payoff almost never happens, in aggregate. And I haven't even included a risk premium, which would make the required payoff higher!
If wealth capture is a main concern, you're better off building a nest egg at a hedge fund or large corporation for 10 years. If you want to start a startup, do it for the culture and technological freedom. From a statistical view, however, a startup is not the optimal way to become rich.
EDIT: mynegation reminded me of risk-adjusted returns. Thanks!
P(becoming rich | working at a startup) != P(worked at a startup | is rich)
I don't want to parse statements here, but it's pretty clear PG suggests that starting up or working at a startup is the best way to become rich. I'd wager that, in practice, people become rich for a variety of reasons, with none being more effective than any other.-----
EDIT: Above, I'm trying to point out how the fraction of rich entrepreneurs vs. rich employees provides us with no information by itself.
However, we can develop a distribution of probabilities for becoming rich based on the career you chose, using the careers of those who are already rich. I'd suppose this is PG's real point, and while I can't verify it right now I'd bet entrepreneurs become rich at a higher frequency than non-entrepreneurs.
Also, apologies for my rude tone. :(
This is clearer if you consider a statement like "10% of men are over 6 feet tall." There's no one who has actually has a 10% chance of being over 6 feet tall. 10% of people have a 100% chance, and the remaining 90% have a 0% chance.
For the sort of person who has sufficient drive to get rich at all, starting a startup is a much more reliable way to do it than the overall success rate implies.
As it turns out there is an easy way to know which group you're in: ask us. Like all venture investors, it's our job to answer that question, and we work very hard to try to do it well.
Your comments preceding and following this sentence suggest that injustice doesn't enter into the equation.
But on the contrary, anyone who's paid attention the past 30 years is well aware that inequality has increased greatly, and that the main reasons are various forms of carefully calculated injustice, such as:
1. Regressive tax policies shifting the tax burden from the wealthy and the corporations to the middle class.
2. Mass wealth transfer scams such as the housing bubble and the S&L scams of the 1980s.
3. Massive spending on foreign wars which benefits a very narrow slice of weapons companies and related businesses - that money could have gone to build up the wealth of the nation, in the form of infrastructure, education, etc.
4. Massive deregulation of the financial industry, which allowed many Wall St. scams to proceed without hindrance.
The glib thinking exemplified by the quoted sentence is typical of "libertarian" ideology that doesn't expend much energy on thinking about the problems cited above.
This is why I ask people who think they disagree with something I've written to find something I actually wrote and refute it. Otherwise more often than not they are (as you are here) arguing against something they mistakenly believe I said rather than something I actually did say.
What I said in the sentence you quote is that a lot of people automatically assume that economic inequality is due to injustice. I never claimed it never is, and in fact it's pretty clear from e.g. this passage I think it often is:
"There are a lot of ways to get rich, and this essay is about only one of them. This essay is about how to make money by creating wealth and getting paid for it. There are plenty of other ways to get money, including chance, speculation, marriage, inheritance, theft, extortion, fraud, monopoly, graft, lobbying, counterfeiting, and prospecting. Most of the greatest fortunes have probably involved several of these."