It took me a long time to realize that Open Source does not imply any responsibility unless you want it to.
If the community decides that your software is 'critical', it is the community's responsibility to maintain it.
We, as maintainers, of course should try to help. But if I'm on vacation, or just simply don't feel like programming, that has to be acceptable. If somebody needs professional support and guaranteed availability, they should pay people to do so. I think this is the central tenet of spare-time OSS maintainership.
Perhaps we'd need a sponsorship model: A button on Github where a customer can negotiate a price with a maintainer for a particular feature or bugfix.