Full disclosure, I work for a Cognito competitor, so I'm definitely talking my book here. But our users are not. Here's a summation.
* There is only one deployment model, a SaaS offering on AWS.
* The user pool and identity pool concepts can be difficult to grasp.
* The user interface presented to your customers is inflexible and hard to customize.
* You can run Cognito only in the geographies supported by AWS.
* Cognito pools are not multi-region. If the AWS region that your pool is in is unavailable, you have few options.
* It doesn’t support localization of messages or the user interface.
* You can’t backup or export all user data, notably password hashes.
* SAML accounts are expensive after you grow beyond the free tier.
* Possibly most concerning, Amazon Cognito has been relatively static and has received few recent improvements over the last few years. The console UX got an overhaul in 2021, though.
* The customizability of the user interface and workflows are lacking.
* Since you can't export your password hashes, if you move to a different provider, you have to reset user passwords or use a drip migration.
Here's a funny video from Corey Quinn about Cognito: https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=x70EypnAH1Y&feat...
That said, I've heard rumors they are working on multi-region Cognito (see this vague tweet from an AWS employee: https://twitter.com/sarah_cecc/status/1486346455790985228 ) which would absolutely be a game changer. And they have a nice serverless model if you can get by with their functionality and deployment model.