Particularly after reading the memos which came out in the Epic lawsuit, I can’t tell how much all of this really is about privacy. Or how much privacy is just cover to take a cut of the profits of Netflix, Amazon and visa by controlling access to our phones.
The privacy argument probably has some truth, but it seems suspiciously self serving for Apple.
I think there’s plenty of ways apple could preserve my privacy without taking such extreme control of my device. A simple answer would be to give banks direct access to the NFC chips on the condition of user privacy. And cut them off if they violate that policy rule.
I don’t think it’s a coincidence that apple’s chosen solution just happens to be the one which maximises their profit.