Bank did its job and processed the payment, why should they be liable for all these?
If anything, your example is an illustration why those "protections" should be abolished.
Bank did its job and processed the payment, why should they be liable for all these?
If anything, your example is an illustration why those "protections" should be abolished.
Because if the bank broke their legal obligations to the customer and the consumer had to use a attorney to recover their money, the attorney deserves to get paid.
Banks are expected to know their customer and to take measures to prevent fraud, rather than watching money go by and shrugging because they made a few nickels.
Externalizing all the risk out to the individual customers doesn't seem like a preferable system. Banks have done a whole lot of work to make the risks associated with this manageable and even profitable.
Consumers are safer, and also it is more reasonable to trust the payment system to have safe outcomes. As a result it is used more, and banks make more money.
the bank is not required to process transactions for an impersonator. the opposite in fact, it's supposed to filter out the fraudster's transaction! even if his password leaked, none of that matters. the transaction is valid only between the bank and the individual, any failure in communication between those two is the bank's problem, it just depends on how loud the scammed consumer is willing to be.
in China today there are people in Henan province that had their money completely stolen from their accounts... by the bank owner! and who's responsible? the central bank of course, and they will all be repaid, and very fast now because they protested very very loudly
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-07-21/china-to-...
people should not have to protest for fairness, the money should have never left their accounts, the system should have been perfect
src: software engineer designing fintech systems
I’m a litigator. The system is defined. The law is defined. I just operate within it.
Those types of questions/concerns are well addressed to your Congressperson. I’m merely letting folks know what the system is.
I don't agree with the parent commenter, but I find this view to be widely held among lawyers, and I find it distasteful.
A good way to respond to the question: why should banks be subject to this risk? Because ultimately leaks like the one described shouldn't happen, the people affected by them should be swiftly made whole, and it's not hard to see that banks are in a better position to ensure this happens than the individuals themselves.
Just because from the consumer's perspective the bank "covered" the losses, there's no reason the bank should be understood to be forced to just eat those costs. If a company like crypto.com is ultimately liable, then the bank can more effectively pursue action, whether there was 1 person affected or if N of their customers suffered losses. In the event that there were multiple customers affected, those losses can be consolidated, and the bank can pursue the ultimately liable party to recover the costs that the bank had to (temporarily) foot the bill for. They're frickin' banks.