I'd love to hear about this business plan.
Now, can we convince Mr Beast to join this platform? No, but I don't think most people will notice a discernible dip in quality. Most exploitation-tubers would probably scuttle off to Facebook or Instagram, but I think most of the Patron-supported content creators would buy-in to a well made alternative. Key operand being well made though...
Servers and other fixed costs can be handled by donations or selling merch.
Tickets and high bandwidth cases may not be a good fit for the project, or may be on a "as available" basis.
IF this was true we would already have a Youtube competitor. We don't.
As torrents demonstrate it's not necessarily bandwidth that's a problem, it's mostly durability and discoverability.
even then it wouldn't be be able to handle the traffic or keep the lights on.
im sorry but you clearly have not thought this through. its just not sustainable with this donation model.
This unquestioned given of "where's the monetisation?" is almost everything that's wrong with the internet today. It's seen as "gown up" and realistic, but doesn't even question it's own wisdom.
We don't have to speculate with hypotheticals on what an unmonetised service would look like either, it's literally how things used to work before the corporate takeover of the web.
EDIT: Though I'd have to add that there are ways to get paid which don't have the same downsides (changing the content to make it easier to monetise). It's like how people prefer films that keep their integrity, instead apealling to the lowest common denominator.
What I'm saying is that monetization changes the way videos are made. They generally tend to be padded out, with intros, attempts at social engagement, ("Please like and subscribe, and let me know how you feel in the comments!"). This style is actively encouraged by YouTube.