I have followed that thread, and the Alzeimer "story" with great interest over the couple years I've been aware of it - in no way was my comment above meant to be a reflection on the possibility of a "taint" or lack-of scientific rigor (to bring in another example - the lack of repeatability in, oh, nearly every(?) social psychology experiment, etc. etc.) in the scientific and medical-science fields. The rise in administration at academic levels at the expense of science, the growing discontent in scientific funding being tied to results rather than curiousity, all very important - and very important to keep a skeptical mind about it all! Absolutely, that, to me, is the core of the scientific excercise.
I only meant that, in this particular case of polio detection, the cause and origin of the case is fairly cut-and-dry (there are other articles that have been published about it that give additional information), and introducing skepticism of the manner I responded to initially is likely to do more harm than good. Disinformation often begins with a distortion of a grain of truth, and the effects of that public skepticism and, dare I say it, ignorance (ironically?) breeds the environment that causes the reemergence of, for example, polio, amongst a public that is just being "skeptical" of vaccines.