Hacker News Reader

Comment by GOATS- | Hacker News Reader

This simply isn't true. Many of my closest friendships started online - with people who share the same interest as me, which is rare to find irl. I have since met a handful of online friends in person and they're always as lovely as they were online.

Online friends were very important to me growing up, and still are today.

View on HN

Everything you’ve said is true, but also you literally cannot replicate in-person interaction. Perhaps one day we will be able to trick our lizard brains with virtual interactions, but we can’t do it at present. There is no replacement for touching, feeling, smelling, and seeing. You can have meaningful relationships online but you are absolutely missing out if you’re only interactions are digital.

I don’t know about you, but I don’t tend to touch, feel, or smell my IRL acquaintances all that often.

I’d love to see the contraption you wear to dull your sense of touch or smell. Must be impressive.

My sense of smell is fine, I just don’t often find the occasion to smell my friends.

But literally no one in this thread is saying otherwise. We’re just saying online friends are real and shouldn’t be demeaned with scare quotes, and also you’re probably missing out if your only interactions are local.

That doesn't actually contradict me.

But nor does what you said really answer my question. Online friends are real, and often provide things that local friends can't. No one here is saying they're a substitute for local friends, but that doesn't mean these relationships should be denigrated.

> But nor does what you said really answer my question.

I answered, but to further clarify: online friendships are not sufficient. No one said they don't have their place, either.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com