Allegedly it's much better now, but this string of 'we fixed all the bugs this time - promise!' posts I'm still having my reservations.
Allegedly it's much better now, but this string of 'we fixed all the bugs this time - promise!' posts I'm still having my reservations.
[1] If they're not, that's even worse.
That's not how it works. Every program that evolves also creates bugs all the time because of bad implementations, bad formulation, bad problem scoping, bad integration. If your project creates more bugs every week than it can possibly fix you can have these weekly bug fixing newsletter forever and at the same time accumulate more bugs than you ever had.
And nobody is claiming all the bugs are fixed. Quite the contrary. There is a huge effort on fixing bugs, but this desktop is overall quite stable. You can try it by yourself, but don't do this if you are happy with your current setup.
I also jumped off the kde train after the 3->4 transition/train wreck. However, about a year ago I gave it another try, basically on a whim, and I was really impressed. Impressed enough that I haven't switched back to XFCE since.
Nowadays, you can just turn off indexing with one checkbox. And it works quite well anyway. It got a lot better. I don't bother disabling it anymore. It does not even cross my mind. A few years ago it was mandatory. Probably also because I was using spinning drives.
KDE5 has been vastly better for me - especially in the last two years or so.
I don't really hit any bugs day to day.
First versions of KDE 5 were very lacking. It's now back to rock solid and much more visually pleasing and enjoyable to use than KDE 4. The Oxygen theme was very visually "heavy", its grey was quite depressing and overall did not look well. I would just get rid of it and switch to the Fusion theme. KDE 3 with its Plastik theme looked a bit more dated than Oxygen, but was way better. KDE 5's Breeze theme is perfect.