It is definitely worth it to use a modern compression format. I regularly take backups of one service I run. Originally I used gzip, and then on someone's recommendation I tried zstd. Here are the results:
gzip compression time: 204s
zstd compression time: 19.1s
gzip decompression time: 28.2s
zstd decompression time: 6.4s
gzip compressed size: 3.0GB
zstd compressed size: 1.7GB
I ain't ever going back to gzip, especially when it wastes so much disk space and CPU cycles.> sane world [..] Solaris
...I think we're living in a different world. (:
You are not getting compatibility out of xz, not even with itself, if you cared about maximum compatibility you'd be using zip (understood and supported by all major OS at this point), and it sounds like if you just cared about compression ratio you'd use lzip...
If it was speed, I could see zstd (or maybe bzip2? not sure how it stacks up), or just compatibility with linux/embedded folks, gzip. The use case for XZ seems actually pretty marginally small, its like holding onto .rar files or some obscure file splitting tool...
lzip might get there eventually, but it's not there now. xz has enough usage behind it that I'm not concerned.
bzip2 has enough usage but the compression ratio is worse. zstd has neither the usage nor the ratio.
The way the author was talking I wouldn't be sure that's even true, if the authors are mucking about with the container format and xz makes some non-compatible breaking change, you may not even know you can't open old xz files with the new version (it reads versions based upon heuristics rather than a version number, IIRC from the article).