I think Earthly is a better replacement for make; but containerized builds are definitely slower (often to a disappointing degree). Luckily Earthly has a ton of knobs you can turn re: caching to make things suck less.
Don’t get me wrong, make is great, but I think it only really shines when you’re using a language like C/C++ where you can use it’s awesome dependency graphs. For projects in Go or JavaScript it quickly becomes a task runner with a very inconvenient syntax.
Earthly gives you a make-esque syntax while doing all of the work in Docker which gives you repeatability and parallelization for free.