"Ok, so you're employed at-will. You are only talking about losing your unvested shares. Your employer has the option to fire you and prevent you from vesting anymore shares, yet he is keeping you on board and wishes to renegotiate the matter of your remaining unvested shares.. Do I have that right?"
"Yes. I want to remain employed, and I want to vest all my unvested shares"
"You realize your employer can perfectly legally just fire you and you will not vest any shares at all, right?"
"Yes, but I want to get all the shares I'm entitled to"
"I realize that, bu you realize your employer can perfectly legally just fire you and you will not vest any shares at all, right?"
"Yes, I guess they can."
"You don't need a lawyer, you have no claim here at all, there is nothing I could do. The underlying assumption of your employer is that you have not been doing a good job. I'm pretty sure they have a paper trail to support their case. You will have to contest that, but first you need to get fired, otherwise there is no harm done. But once that happens the onus will be on you to prove that you were fired for an illegal reason, and that is a very high standard to meet. Very high."
"Hmm, ok"
"Now, let's see what 'at-will employment' means: 'The employer is free to discharge individuals "for good cause, or bad cause, or no cause at all," and the employee is equally free to quit, strike, or otherwise cease work.'"
"Oh shit."
"Maybe you better negotiate for your remaining unvested shares. Some shares are better than no shares. You could be getting fired right now for all I know. You could bring me in to help you negotiate, but if I were them and my employee brought in a lawyer to negotiate, I would fire him on the spot rather than play a game I don't need to play."
"Damn."