You update your workstation one day to find the distro put a new UI on it. OK, this is interesting but you need to get on with some work, so you just switch back to the old one. That option's gone. Hmm, OK well let's have a quick play with this new thing... Wait, you can't move anything around to where you're used to? WTF. And there are whole different window-interaction paradigms, odd choices about workspaces over window manipulation. Huh... well at least you can still run the programs you need to. Wait, why isn't the messenger app you need for work appearing in the notification area? What is that in the notification area? A different app that you can't remove, don't need and with no way to replace it? WTF.
OK you really do need to go back to the old version. But the distro repos don't even have it, so you can't even install it. WTF? Is it just gone? You were just using that yesterday!
You go online to investigate and find out there's been this major update, some distros have switched to it already, and it seems like it was a deliberate choice to make it impossible to run the old thing alongside. The old thing is now abandonware, instantly, and if you want to work the way you have been for the last ten years, you're wrong, old fashioned, out of date, stifling open source and generally a problem. Wow OK.
Does that explain it OK?
I'm not saying the vitriol online is all justified, but this is how a lot of us first encountered Gnome 3/Shell. Personally at that point I'd already been using Xfce on a low-powered machine, so I just switched over, and within a couple of minutes I had my desktop back how I like it, and got on with my life. But I'll always remember that at some point the Gnome folks (and the distros share some blame) actively ripped away my way of working, and told me I was a dick for not thanking them for it.
Overtime the stupid choices of gtk3 are getting on my nerves more and more. Now I have to patch the crap just to be able to navigate in the file browser by typing the begining of filenames (the default now starts a laggy and buggy file search. they removed the old code).
No. The things you are saying are completely normal and expected, and I cannot see why you would be upset by that if you had been updating a Linux system (or any OS) for the years prior to that. Every OS has changed their UI, some have done it several times. Remember the initial switch to Windows 8, or MacOS X, or from GNOME 1 to GNOME 2? And even before that, how Linux distributions had frequently been switching between window managers or from GNOME to KDE and vice versa? It makes no sense to me to take issue with this one specific case. For a project that is trying to keep attracting new users, it is unreasonable to expect them to never change anything or never refactor the UI.
The real WTF is using something like XFCE and expecting nothing to change for 20 or more years, that is totally out of the ordinary with any comparable retail tech product.
They really aren't.
> Remember the initial switch to Windows 8
Yes, it was terrible, people hated the change and that it was hard to make it work like the older versions, it's still famous for being horrible and unusable and MS basically rolled it back in the face of overwhelming criticism. (Windows 8 is actually a really good point of comparison here, I never claimed that only the gnome people have done this)
> Linux distributions had frequently been switching between window managers or from GNOME to KDE and vice versa
Yep, and you could always switch back and forth, easily. Gnome 3 was scorched earth.
> The real WTF is using something like XFCE and expecting nothing to change for 20 or more years
Yet here I am, and here most people on Windows are, and on OS X. MacOS X from 2001 is still recognisable today. Move the start button on Windows 11 to the left and you've basically got an evolved Win 95/NT 4.
Evolutionary changes and improvements are great. People choosing to work differently is great. Designers exploring different ways of working, great. Wading in and hamfistedly breaking everything about how people work, then telling them they're wrong for wanting to keep working that way, is virtually never well received.
Actually they are, I cannot name a single system that has not changed in some significant ways since the 90s, unless development has slowed to the point where it basically stopped and became a time capsule.
>Yes, it was terrible, people hated the change and that it was hard to make it work like the older versions, it's still famous for being horrible and unusable and MS basically rolled it back in the face of overwhelming criticism.
I think this is still a poor example to illustrate your point. They rolled back some aspects, other aspects were changed in Windows 10 and now again in Windows 11.
>I never claimed that only the gnome people have done this
Yes, my point was that they all do it. It makes no sense to fixate on GNOME doing this.
>Yep, and you could always switch back and forth, easily. Gnome 3 was scorched earth.
I am not sure what this is supposed to mean. You could always switch easily, even now there are many distros that offer GNOME as only an option, or do not really have GNOME as a supported option at all. Maybe you were using a distro that only supported one option, but it was always within their authority to do that just like they could decide to only offer KDE Plasma as an option. So this complaint still makes no sense to me.
>Yet here I am, and here most people on Windows are, and on OS X. MacOS X from 2001 is still recognisable today. Move the start button on Windows 11 to the left and you've basically got an evolved Win 95/NT 4.
Again that is describing one specific area, other things have been completely redone or rewritten. And I have spoken to some other people who were very bothered by that change and didn't like it.
>Evolutionary changes and improvements are great. People choosing to work differently is great. Designers exploring different ways of working, great. Wading in and hamfistedly breaking everything about how people work, then telling them they're wrong for wanting to keep working that way, is virtually never well received.
Just to clarify, it is very possible for a user to be wrong about something. If someone is telling you they are never wrong, that will virtually never be well received either. It is very hard for me to interpret this in a way other than that you're describing changes that don't bother you as "evolutionary" but ones that do bother you as "hamfisted". Try to be a little bit more objective about this, perhaps if you feel like it, go through a list of many changes across these and compare them. You might be surprised as to what you find.