Things IRC is better at:
– being light weight (both server and clients)
– being an open standard
– horizontal scaling
– simplicity (talk to it over telnet if you want)
Things every other modern messaging solution is better at:
– name and channel management
– permissions that are more granular than ability to access a channel or not
– non-textual content (images/video/emoji)
– rich text (HTML/markdown/syntax highlighting/typefaces/fonts)
– one to one/many to many calls and meetings in a world with everyone behind a NAT and middleboxes
– file transfers
– screen sharing
– mobile connectivity
– threading
– message history/ability to receive messages while not online
– aesthetics and UX (most IRC clients resemble TUI apps)
– accurate presence (whether a given person is actually available or not, attempts to paper over missing IRC features with things like bouncers usually break this and the offered features are usually more granular than connected or not connected)
– extensibility (/commands and "chatops")
– abuse control and prevention
Things that do not matter to the world at large:
– That you personally are not a fan of the modern solutions and/or find them distracting
– That modern messaging solutions are centralized rather than distributed
– That a new IRC standard is on the way that addresses most of IRC's deficiencies… Two decades too late.
– Privacy policies and TOSes that allow platform owners to target ads at users or "sell their data"
– That a variety of clients for each service is not available
– The availability of and license to the source code for the client and server
Reasons why (insert name of decentralized project) is unlikely to displace the centralized incumbents anytime soon:
– Their UX is worse or they are lacking a significant number of features
– Users don't want to run servers or deal with technical minutia, and the alternative requires these
– The problems this project solves are mostly on the list of things that do not matter to the world at large