If a bully extorts an entire class for lunch money, except for one kid who's on the wrestling team, the bully did not pay for the wrestler's lunch.
I don't mean to be flippant, but engaging with a disconnected hypothetical takes away from the discussion of reality. In my original comment, I believe I sufficiently communicated that I disagree that taxes are extortion. In the context of funding libraries and churches, I don't think that disagreement is going to lead us anywhere.